Magazine | February 23, 2015, Issue

Letters

Contraception, Continued

Robert VerBruggen agues that pro-lifers should support the promotion of contraceptives that sometimes may act as abortifacients (“On a LARC,” December 31). The death rate for unimplanted embryos is high, he points out. He then posits that if we had a moral imperative to prevent an embryo from being killed, we would have an equal duty to try to prevent its natural death. But the lengths to which we would have to go to prevent its natural death would be “absurd enough to call into serious question the premise that unimplanted embryos must be protected” at all.

No, what is absurd is the notion that, if we forgo heroic measures to save a human life from natural death, we have no moral ground to stand on when we try to save it from death by artificial means. Here VerBruggen backs into the “Oxfam argument,” formulated by Peter Singer: Every dollar you spend on a cup of coffee is a dollar you don’t send to a charity that could provide food or medicine to people for whom it is all that stands between them and death. Drink your coffee, but know that you have just killed someone. So there’s no sound reason for trying to stop Boko Haram from finishing the job for you.

As many of us know who have had to give directions to doctors reporting that an elderly family member was dying, sometimes heroic measures would not even be for the better, although the difference between when they would be and when failure to take such measures amounts to a sin of omission is never clear and certain. Always clear and certain, however, is the difference between letting someone die and hastening her death. VerBruggen’s blindness to this distinction is the weak link in his argument, which otherwise is careful, fair-minded, and free of rancor. No small achievement, given the strong emotions surrounding this issue.

Melissa Klimchock

Brecksville, Ohio

Robert VerBruggen responds: My argument is not quite the Oxfam argument: I am not saying that causing the death of X and failing to save X are morally equivalent. I am saying that if we value X and Y equally, not only will we give X and Y the same protection from artificial harm, but we will go to the same lengths (whatever those are) to save them.

That said, Ms. Klimchock is correct that sometimes it can be best, if heartbreaking, to let loved ones die of natural causes. But we allow this only in certain situations — specifically, when there is little hope that medical intervention would do more than delay the inevitable. So this analogy might apply in certain cases where a woman’s body keeps an embryo from implanting (such as when, due to a genetic disorder, her child would be destined to have a painful and very short life), but it wouldn’t hold up in others (e.g., if her body were aborting a healthy embryo, or an embryo with a genetic problem more akin to Down syndrome).

Members of the National Review editorial and operational teams are included under the umbrella “NR Staff.”

In This Issue

Articles

Politics & Policy

A Hand Withheld

It’s rare for a president to conclude a State of the Union address with a long passage noting that his presidency “hasn’t delivered” on one of its central promises. President ...

Features

Politics & Policy

Foreign Policy by Map

George W. Bush left office with his activist foreign policy in disrepute. Fast-forward six years: President Barack Obama has pursued, in some respects, the opposite approach, and yet he has ...

Books, Arts & Manners

City Desk

The City, from Afar

The road follows the right angles of everything out here, farms, townships, counties, states. On either side, fields showing stubble. Thick gnarly trees mark homesteads and cemeteries. Where the land ...
Politics & Policy

Midcentury Mores

Edward Mendelson is one of our mandarin humanistic intellectuals — Lionel Trilling Professor in the Humanities at Columbia, literary executor of the estate of W. H. Auden, an expert on ...
Politics & Policy

Bloody Crossroads Redux

There have been two great political wars this Oscar season, and both have involved American liberals’ complex relationship with the movies. What makes this relationship complicated is that liberals have ...

Sections

Politics & Policy

Letters

Contraception, Continued Robert VerBruggen agues that pro-lifers should support the promotion of contraceptives that sometimes may act as abortifacients (“On a LARC,” December 31). The death rate for unimplanted embryos is ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ Vaccines seem to do strange things to the mind — at least for politicians. ‐ Wisconsin governor Scott Walker took an early, if narrow, lead in a poll of Iowa Republicans. ...
Athwart

Lifespan Liberalism

There’s no shortage of studies that attempt to show how liberals and conservatives are different species who happen to share hominid form. Liberals are conveniently revealed by Cold Science to ...
Politics & Policy

Poetry

THE MESSENGER This blind matter troubleth my wit.                                                              Everyman We waited for the messenger all night, A mixed report though certainly it shocks, When summoning what little souls we have He drums them like dumb echoes ...

Most Popular

World

The End of Hong Kong as We Know It

The protests in Hong Kong have been going on for more than four months now, and no matter how the current crisis concludes in the coming days or weeks, it will mark the end of Hong Kong as we know it. The protests started in response to an extradition bill that was proposed by the city’s Beijing-backed ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Hillary Ruins the Plan

Editor’s note: Andrew C. McCarthy’s new book is Ball of Collusion: The Plot to Rig an Election and Destroy a Presidency. This is the first in a series of excerpts.  There really was a collusion plot. It really did target our election system. It absolutely sought to usurp our capacity for ... Read More
Religion

Another Pop-Culture Christian Loses His Faith

It’s happened again. For the second time in three weeks, a prominent (at least in Evangelical circles) Christian has renounced his faith. In July, it was Josh Harris, a pastor and author of the mega-best-selling purity-culture book I Kissed Dating Goodbye. This month, it’s Hillsong United songwriter and ... Read More
Elections

A Brief History of Election Meddling

Editor’s note: Andrew C. McCarthy’s new book is Ball of Collusion: The Plot to Rig an Election and Destroy a Presidency. This is the second in a series of excerpts. ‘The 1980s are now calling to ask for their foreign policy back.” Thus spoke President Barack Obama just a couple of weeks before ... Read More
Culture

An Insider’s Guide to Italian Insults

The tragicomic irony of Chris Cuomo’s pugilistic outburst earlier this week — cursing and physically threatening a man for taunting him with a reference to the movie The Godfather — is that the CNN anchor reinforced the usual tropes about Italian Americans. We are all wise-guys, goons, and Mafiosi, just ... Read More