Magazine May 18, 2015, Issue

Letters

The Germ of Corruption

In his review of my book A Republic No More: Big Government and the Rise of American Political Corruption (April 20), Matthew Spalding states that I offer a “neo-anti-federalist account” of corruption, and that the Bank of the United States heralded an era of “living constitutionalism,” facilitating a “slippery slope” of “rampant corruption.” This inaccurate characterization elides key points of my theory and ignores most of my research.

The Anti-Federalists thought the new government was too powerful and removed from the people, whereas I am concerned with the process by which government authority increases. This self-consciously Madisonian approach is hardly the stuff of Brutus or Federal Farmer. At one point I even recommend Hamilton’s quasi-monarchical plan, given the powers the government eventually acquired.

Moreover, my treatment of the Bank explicitly avoids constitutional hermeneutics. My modest point is that because the Framers did not anticipate the Bank, they did not build institutions to ensure it would behave well. Even so, I aver that the Bank was hardly corrupt in the grand scheme, and I celebrate Hamilton’s “sound and sure management.” It is a relatively benign metaphor for my theory: an early indication of a process that would eventually cause problems.

Per Spalding, I see the Framers as the “fathers of big government.” I would never make such a claim. My analysis of the early Republic has less to do with the (small) size of government or the (modest) level of corruption; rather, it outlines the early development of a methodology that, “perfected” over time, would eventually yield corruption.

The early Republic takes up only about a tenth of my book, which focuses primarily on the progressive era and beyond. This is when government truly broke free of its restraints. Spalding glosses over the bulk of this research and misunderstands the role that the early Republic plays in my analysis.

Jay Cost

Matthew Spalding responds: Jay Cost’s fine book is best when it describes the corruptions of the Gilded Age and the rise and proliferation of modern liberalism and interest-group politics. But a key question for both history and future policy is, How did we get here? Cost is right that the progressive movement was “a reimagining of American republicanism,” and what comes after the New Deal is “an inflection point” in the story. But throughout he presents Hamilton’s bank and its early embrace of expansive government as “a microcosm of the argument in this book,” which leaves the general narrative on a downward  slope from the very beginning. This suggests that an extended but limited republic may not be possible after all, just as the Anti-Federalists predicted. The alternative is a fundamental break in thought and practice between the Founders’ constitutionalism and the progressive project. This analysis also helps us see the possibility of a Madisonian solution to our current dilemmas rather than accept an inherent corruption in republican government that is here to stay.

Members of the National Review editorial and operational teams are included under the umbrella “NR Staff.”

In This Issue

Articles

Politics & Policy

Sci-Fi’s Sad Puppies

It turns out that pop culture doesn’t inexorably drift toward political correctness. The forces of “social justice” are not invincible, and conservative artists do have cultural power. Just ask the ...
Politics & Policy

Drowning in Propaganda

In February, a rusty, decrepit freighter named the East Sea ran aground on the Côte d’Azur near Saint-Tropez. Its captain and crew fled, and when police and medical teams arrived ...

Features

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

It’s the Parents

Almost all Americans agree that our society ought to strive for equality of opportunity — that no child’s prospects should be limited by the circumstances of his or her birth. ...
Politics & Policy

I, Ava

Perhaps the most surprising thing about Ex Machina, a claustrophobic science-fiction movie in which two very different men orbit the female artificial intelligence one of them created, is that the ...
City Desk

Horns of Plenty

The ground floor of our apartment building in the city presents a row of storefronts to the avenue: a pizzeria, a nail salon, a walk-in medical clinic, a supermarket, and ...

Sections

Politics & Policy

Letters

The Germ of Corruption In his review of my book A Republic No More: Big Government and the Rise of American Political Corruption (April 20), Matthew Spalding states that I offer ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ When Clinton became secretary of state and said she would build stronger relations with foreign countries, she really meant it. ‐ On the morning of April 12, Freddie Gray was ...
Athwart

The More You Know

News Brief: Kraft Foods, after a prolonged campaign by a “healthy food” blogger, announced it would remove the chemicals that give mac & cheese its distinctive hue. For a long ...
The Long View

Pool Report

March 22, 2017 POOL REPORT WHITE HOUSE PRESS CORPS 06:30 President Jenner enters the White House gym for her usual calisthenics ritual. Your pool reporter witnessed a strenuous treadmill workout followed by a ...
Politics & Policy

Poetry

CATHEDRAL The inner light grandeur of the cathedral, muted but still present, even on cloudy days; its immensity, its echoes, silence, its music, shifting uplift of daylight, its faithful, its tourists, clergy, its pattern of life; ...
Happy Warrior

From Reason to Treason

‘Our age,” Julien Benda wrote in The Treason of the Intellectuals, “is indeed the age of the intellectual organization of political hatreds.” That came to mind recently when I saw the ...

Most Popular

Why Trump’s Losing

President Trump pulled an inside straight to win in 2016, and now he needs another one. The good news for Trump is that his approval rating has stopped falling recently. The bad news is that it has stabilized in the low 40s. Election-watcher Harry Enten points out that no president since Harry Truman has won ... Read More

Why Trump’s Losing

President Trump pulled an inside straight to win in 2016, and now he needs another one. The good news for Trump is that his approval rating has stopped falling recently. The bad news is that it has stabilized in the low 40s. Election-watcher Harry Enten points out that no president since Harry Truman has won ... Read More
U.S.

A Stay-at-Home Mom on Her Reasons for Leaving Portland

While covering events (see here and here) in Portland, Ore., National Review writer Luther Abel sat down with Joanna -- a college-educated, stay-at-home mom and now Trump voter -- who feels it is no longer safe or healthy to live there. They discussed the change that has happened in the city politically, the ... Read More
U.S.

A Stay-at-Home Mom on Her Reasons for Leaving Portland

While covering events (see here and here) in Portland, Ore., National Review writer Luther Abel sat down with Joanna -- a college-educated, stay-at-home mom and now Trump voter -- who feels it is no longer safe or healthy to live there. They discussed the change that has happened in the city politically, the ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The World’s Worst Idea

Almost a decade ago, I wrote a little book called The Politically Incorrect Guide to Socialism. When Regnery asked me to write the book, I was happy to do it but wondered whether a book on socialism, a brief conspectus of its grotesque failures, would be necessary or useful. I wondered why anybody would be ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The World’s Worst Idea

Almost a decade ago, I wrote a little book called The Politically Incorrect Guide to Socialism. When Regnery asked me to write the book, I was happy to do it but wondered whether a book on socialism, a brief conspectus of its grotesque failures, would be necessary or useful. I wondered why anybody would be ... Read More
Film & TV

Laughing at Beyoncé’s Absolute Monarchy

Back in the Nineties, when hip-hop zealots questioned the intelligence of Beyoncé songs like Destiny’s Child’s careerist anthem “Survivor” and the sex-as-junk-food hit “Bootylicious,” there was little regard for the female agency that she now channels into an intersectional act, trading on gender and ... Read More
Film & TV

Laughing at Beyoncé’s Absolute Monarchy

Back in the Nineties, when hip-hop zealots questioned the intelligence of Beyoncé songs like Destiny’s Child’s careerist anthem “Survivor” and the sex-as-junk-food hit “Bootylicious,” there was little regard for the female agency that she now channels into an intersectional act, trading on gender and ... Read More
Politics & Policy

What Next?

Imagine this: You have a friend who has never saved a penny for his retirement. You ask him about it when he is in his twenties, and he says, “No problem — I’m going to win the lottery.” Years go by. You ask him about it in his thirties, in his forties, in his fifties, etc., and get the same answer. At ... Read More
Politics & Policy

What Next?

Imagine this: You have a friend who has never saved a penny for his retirement. You ask him about it when he is in his twenties, and he says, “No problem — I’m going to win the lottery.” Years go by. You ask him about it in his thirties, in his forties, in his fifties, etc., and get the same answer. At ... Read More