Magazine November 2, 2015, Issue

Letters

Lord Kelvin, Out of Context?

Robert Zubrin (“The Human Factor,” September 21) may well be right to deny that global warming poses a risk of catastrophic problems. Part of his case for that denial, however, rests on statistical sleight-of-hand.

Zubrin says that, over the past 50 years, the result of unconstrained emission of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere has been an increase in the global mean temperature of only 0.2 percent. The temperature went from 287 K to 288 K. He is right — if you measure global temperatures on the Kelvin scale. But why does he choose a scale that starts at absolute zero? 

In astrobiology, “habitable zone” refers to the region in which a planet orbiting its sun can have liquid water. Planets outside the habitable zone cannot support life. The freezing point of water is 273 K. Thus, 273 K marks the lower bound of any plausibly relevant scale measuring changes in mean global surface temperature. (Indeed, it sets the lower bound conservatively.)

Here, then, is the statistical sleight-of-hand. Zubrin employs a scale that has the current global mean temperature at 288 K. But on that very scale, every possible mean temperature from 0 K to 273 K is irrelevant. If instead we measure changes in Celsius — a scale on which 0 marks the freezing point of water — we see that the average global mean temperature has increased from 14 to 15 degrees. That is an increase of about 7 percent. Maybe that is a catastrophic increase, maybe it is not. But putting the temperature numbers that way at least gives the public a real sense of the scale of the problem. Measuring global temperatures in kelvins does not.

Neil A. Manson

Oxford, Miss.

Robert Zubrin responds: The average global temperature has increased 0.6 degrees Celsius over the past 60 years. This is 0.2 percent of the absolute temperature, or 1 percent of the range (–25 to +35 degrees Celsius) experienced in my home state of Colorado, among many other places, in the course of a single year. In either case, it is trivial in comparison with the 15 percent increase in the rate of plant growth and the 400 percent increase in average global GDP per capita caused by the unconstrained use of carbon-based fuels over the same period. Moreover, there is no evidence to support the contention that the climate of the 1950s was in any way preferable to that of today, let alone the idea that the barely detectable temperature increase represents some sort of catastrophe — which it would certainly have to be to outweigh the enormous increase in living standards made possible by fossil fuels.

Members of the National Review editorial and operational teams are included under the umbrella “NR Staff.”

In This Issue

Articles

Politics & Policy

Boldly Go

A flurry of space movies has fluttered out of Hollywood over the past few years. Generally speaking, movies skew toward the trivial side of the news spectrum — but the ...

Features

Politics & Policy

Chairman Priebus

On a sunny Friday morning in January 2015, Reince Priebus stood inside the main ballroom of an elegant Southern California resort wearing a conqueror’s smile. The 42-year-old Wisconsinite, a placid-looking ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

The iFranzen

The publication of a new Jonathan Franzen novel has a lot in common with the release of a new iPhone: Both early-autumn events are greeted with absurd amounts of anticipation, ...

Sections

Politics & Policy

Letters

Lord Kelvin, Out of Context? Robert Zubrin (“The Human Factor,” September 21) may well be right to deny that global warming poses a risk of catastrophic problems. Part of his case ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ If Bernie Sanders is tired of hearing about Clinton scandals now, he should just wait till she’s president. ‐ Hillary Clinton came out against the TPP (Trans-Pacific Partnership), a trade ...
Athwart

New Lamps for Old

Next week’s shocking headline: Ben Carson Compares Bush-Era Energy Policy to Nazi Germany. How would that happen? Simple. Let’s back up a bit. A while ago I had an issue with ...
The Long View

Memorandum: CONFIDENTIAL

TO: POTUS FROM: MEDIA TEAM SUBJ: MANHOOD We’ve digested and analyzed the focus-group results from our weekend surveys, and have compiled those along with the results of our snap cellphone poll Sunday night. ...
Politics & Policy

Poetry

SLUMBERING ORION As first light gently pulls the dawn across the earth, Supine Orion readies his bed for the dream of day, and Slumbers within sight of the tranquil Pleiades Now cloaked by the ...
Happy Warrior

The Napier Doctrine

Some of you probably know the story, but too many people don’t. So I will repeat it here. General Charles Napier was the British commander-in-chief of colonial India. His most ...

Most Popular