Magazine | February 15, 2016, Issue


(Brian Snyder/Reuters)

A People and Their Idea

Of the many fine essays in National Review’s 60th-anniversary issue (November 19, 2015), perhaps none rewards careful reading and reflection as much as John O’Sullivan’s “A People, Not Just an Idea.” So first and above all, I want to thank him.

As I read, I was struck by his statement that “an American identity rooted in cultural familiarity will be more genuinely liberal than one attached to the American idea” because “it allows someone to reject the dominant ethos of his society without losing his claim to be an American.” The question arises: What do we mean by “cultural familiarity”? (Surely nothing so trivial as the names of NFL teams.) The answer is suggested, perhaps, when Mr. O’Sullivan later says that “if Americans are a distinct people, with their own history, traditions, institutions, and common culture, then they can reasonably claim that immigrants should adapt to them and to their society rather than the reverse.” “Culture” appears alongside the terms I have italicized, but perhaps history, traditions, and institutions are better understood as constituents of culture.

Now our legal and political institutions certainly embody the liberal principles of the “American idea.” And basic familiarity with American history and traditions — which, as the essay makes clear, do not derive from a single ethnic group or religion and evolve over time — is a precondition for participation in those liberal institutions (and in the liberal American economy), for the simple reason that a separate people cannot readily take a place of equal standing in our civic and economic life. We might mention a common language, too.

So to my mind, the American idea and the American common culture are not competing ways of understanding American identity. Rather, the idea guides us toward a humane and reasonable understanding of which aspects of the culture should matter. Mr. O’Sullivan is surely right that, in the abstract, liberalism does not distinguish America from other liberal nations. But it has played — and plays still — a decisive role in preventing American cultural identity from becoming narrow and exclusionary. It has played that role to a unique degree in world history, and in a way of which Americans are uniquely conscious. And in that sense, I think it is true rather than paradoxical to say that America is not just a people, but also an idea.

Conrad Ensign

Via e-mail

John O’Sullivan responds: I am grateful to Conrad Ensign for his kind remarks on my essay, and even our disagreements seem rooted in a common outlook. I see the American idea less as competing with cultural nationhood than as a useful but inadequate distillation of it — Cliff Notes to the Federalist Papers. It might keep America from being exclusionary, as he argues, but the concept of “Un-Americanness” shows how it can be used to exclude internally when separated from the rich culture of American liberty. For instance, how does the American idea cope with the native American Marxist? He denies the American idea but he can’t be denied entry to American institutions? At least in principle the idea insinuates disloyalty but offers no solution to it. A broader cultural concept holds that an American is likely to be a less consistent Marxist in practice than someone brought up in a despotic culture. (Orwell pointed out that radical critics of English liberalism would sometimes slip and declare in outraged tones that some measure or other was a betrayal of the high standards of British liberty.) And, finally, the American idea offers little or no reply to multiculturalism even though the danger that a separate people might “readily take a place of equal standing in our civic and economic life” is no longer entirely theoretical.

Members of the National Review editorial and operational teams are included under the umbrella “NR Staff.”

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

The Bernie Tax

In late January, during a town-hall forum at Drake University in Des Moines, Iowa, Bernie Sanders, a senator from Vermont and Hillary Clinton’s chief rival for the Democratic presidential nomination, ...


Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

A Man in Full

American administrations don’t fall silent when their president leaves office. Just the opposite: Inauguration Day for the successor is the starting gun for memoirists and journalists-turned-historians. The modern exception has been ...
Politics & Policy

The Big Liar

In Mein Kampf, Adolf Hitler discussed the use of a lie so “colossal” that no one would believe that someone “could have the impudence to distort the truth so infamously.” ...
Politics & Policy

Fog of War

The phrase “a restrained Michael Bay movie” has the same inherent tension as, say, “a tasteful Donald Trump property” or “a platonic hug from William Jefferson Clinton.” Combine Michael Bay ...


Politics & Policy


A People and Their Idea Of the many fine essays in National Review’s 60th-anniversary issue (November 19, 2015), perhaps none rewards careful reading and reflection as much as John O’Sullivan’s “A ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ We appreciate the concern, Donald, and we’ll be sure to consult with you should we ever need advice about bankruptcy. ‐ If the GOP race comes down to Trump or ...
Politics & Policy


MUSK AND MYRRH Indebted to the camel covering I wore on our first evening, with the Oriental mist of Opium by Saint Laurent sprayed on my wrist, I drop the empty bottle, and slide ...

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

Hillary Ruins the Plan

Editor’s note: Andrew C. McCarthy’s new book is Ball of Collusion: The Plot to Rig an Election and Destroy a Presidency. This is the first in a series of excerpts.  There really was a collusion plot. It really did target our election system. It absolutely sought to usurp our capacity for ... Read More

Another Pop-Culture Christian Loses His Faith

It’s happened again. For the second time in three weeks, a prominent (at least in Evangelical circles) Christian has renounced his faith. In July, it was Josh Harris, a pastor and author of the mega-best-selling purity-culture book I Kissed Dating Goodbye. This month, it’s Hillsong United songwriter and ... Read More

Max Boot’s Dishonesty

Before yesterday, my primary criticism of the Washington Post’s Max Boot was political in nature. As I wrote in a recent book review, I found it regrettable that Boot’s opposition to the president had not prevented him from “succumbing reactively to Trump’s cult of personality, or from making Trump the ... Read More

A Brief History of Election Meddling

Editor’s note: Andrew C. McCarthy’s new book is Ball of Collusion: The Plot to Rig an Election and Destroy a Presidency. This is the second in a series of excerpts. ‘The 1980s are now calling to ask for their foreign policy back.” Thus spoke President Barack Obama just a couple of weeks before ... Read More

The End of Hong Kong as We Know It

The protests in Hong Kong have been going on for more than four months now, and no matter how the current crisis concludes in the coming days or weeks, it will mark the end of Hong Kong as we know it. The protests started in response to an extradition bill that was proposed by the city’s Beijing-backed ... Read More