Magazine August 27, 2018, Issue

Cold and Caring Critic

William Giraldi
American Audacity: In Defense of Literary Daring, by William Giraldi (Liveright, 336 pp., $30)

Sixty years ago, Oscar Cargill, a scholar of Henry James and Thomas Wolfe, wrote about the personality and role of the critic. Critics should be “brave” and “generous”; they should be “willing to labor to entertain.” They should, at all costs, avoid “reviewmanship,” the practice “of writing a prescribed number of words for a review without ever saying anything that could possibly offend the publisher-advertiser of the book reviewed.” It is a fine art, in that the critic says “nothing” but is adept at “sprinkling one or two bright phrases which may be dexterously lifted from that context for later

To Read the Full Story

In This Issue

Articles

The Gun Issue

Features

Books, Arts & Manners

Sections

Recommended

The Latest