Magazine October 1, 2018, Issue

Originalism: A Logical Necessity

If we don’t stick to the Constitution’s meaning as written, we have no Constitution.

There is only one proper way to faithfully interpret the Constitution. And that is to ascertain the actual meaning of the words of the text, taken in their proper social and linguistic context.

That meaning must be the objective meaningnot the reader’s subjective understanding or preferred reading. And that meaning must be the original meaningthat is, the meaning the Constitution’s words and phrases would have had to reasonably informed readers of the English language at the time they were used, in context, and accounting for any specialized usages or term-of-art phrases. Any other reading is pure anachronism,

In This Issue

Articles

In Defense of the Constitutional Order

Books, Arts & Manners

Sections

Letters

Letters

Kevin D. Williamson responds to a reader's thoughts on his article, “More Important than Motorcycles.”
The Week

The Week

This just in: Cory Booker says he took an extra packet of sugar at the diner this morning -- and he’d do it again!

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

The Insanity Oath

Conservatives sense that social progressives have achieved a critical level of consolidation in key institutions: the Democratic Party, the university, and the prestige media. The occasional purges of old-school liberals from these institutions testify to that fact. The way that progressives have made ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Insanity Oath

Conservatives sense that social progressives have achieved a critical level of consolidation in key institutions: the Democratic Party, the university, and the prestige media. The occasional purges of old-school liberals from these institutions testify to that fact. The way that progressives have made ... Read More
White House

Trump’s Ugly Exit

No one expected Donald Trump to handle a defeat in the 2020 election well. It was predictable he’d deny that he really lost and allege the vote was rigged, that he’d tweet wild and misleading things, and that he’d lash out in absurd and sophomoric ways. All that was inevitable. What’s been more ... Read More
White House

Trump’s Ugly Exit

No one expected Donald Trump to handle a defeat in the 2020 election well. It was predictable he’d deny that he really lost and allege the vote was rigged, that he’d tweet wild and misleading things, and that he’d lash out in absurd and sophomoric ways. All that was inevitable. What’s been more ... Read More
Health Care

The Gruesome Record of Gavin Newsom

The revelation that California governor Gavin Newsom attended a crowded dinner party at an expensive restaurant in his state just as its coronavirus cases started to surge and he began to lock down its economy more aggressively is one of the most egregious examples of late of the kind of cynicism-inducing ... Read More
Health Care

The Gruesome Record of Gavin Newsom

The revelation that California governor Gavin Newsom attended a crowded dinner party at an expensive restaurant in his state just as its coronavirus cases started to surge and he began to lock down its economy more aggressively is one of the most egregious examples of late of the kind of cynicism-inducing ... Read More
Elections

No, This Isn’t True Either

Trump and his legal team have focused on vote dumps as evidence of fraud. Here’s Trump yesterday: https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/1329233502139715586?s=21 But this is an artifact of the way the count was conducted, as our friend Henry Olsen notes ... Read More
Elections

No, This Isn’t True Either

Trump and his legal team have focused on vote dumps as evidence of fraud. Here’s Trump yesterday: https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/1329233502139715586?s=21 But this is an artifact of the way the count was conducted, as our friend Henry Olsen notes ... Read More