When Victor Davis Hanson and Ralph Peters recently returned from Iraq with good news to report, both were written off for being apologists for the Bush administration. I wonder what their critics have to say now that David “Arrogance of Power” Ignatius is reporting the same things:
BAGHDAD — Three years on, the U.S. military is finally becoming adept at fighting a counterinsurgency war in Iraq. Sadly, these are precisely the skills that should have been mastered before America launched its invasion in March 2003. It may prove one of the costliest lessons in the history of modern warfare.
I had a chance to see the new counterinsurgency doctrine in practice here this week. U.S. troops are handing off to the Iraqi army a growing share of the security burden. As the Iraqis step up, the Americans are stepping back into a training and advisory role. This is the way it should have happened from the beginning. […]
I wouldn’t pretend that these two snapshots are an accurate representation of the whole of Iraq. If that were so, the country wouldn’t be in such a mess. But this is the way this war is supposed to be going. It’s a few years late, but the new U.S. strategy is moving in the right direction.
I think Hanson and Peters are owed an apology.