News

NR PLUS Law & the Courts

Media, Activists, Politicians Ignore Evidence, Rush to Conclusions in Ma’Khia Bryant Shooting

By
A police vehicle drives past a Black Lives Matter flag during a demonstration in Columbus, Ohio, April 20, 2021. (Gaelen Morse/Reuters)

They won’t let the body-camera footage stand in the way of their narrative.

Sign in here to read more.

Hours after former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin was convicted on Tuesday, media and activists tried to cram the police shooting of Ma’Khia Bryant into a pre-ordained narrative box, taking advantage of the incident’s proximity to Chauvin’s conviction to cast the shooting of an armed teenager, who was in the act of stabbing someone, as yet another example of the kind of brutality visited upon George Floyd.

Columbus police responded to a 911 call on Tuesday evening to find a group of teenage girls in a physical altercation in a suburban front yard. Body-camera footage shows that an unnamed officer exited his vehicle and commanded the brawling girls to “get down” before shooting 16-year-old Ma’Khia Bryant four times. Freeze-frame images  show that Bryant was swinging her knife toward another African-American girl in a pink sweatsuit as she was shot.

“She had a knife. She just ran at her,” the officer can be heard saying.

Hazel Bryant, who identified herself as the victim’s aunt, confirmed to The Columbus Dispatch that her niece did have a knife, but said she dropped it before being shot — an anecdote picked up and widely reported by national media, including the New York Times, before the body-camera footage had been released.

Columbus mayor Andrew J. Ginther, a Democrat, called the events “a horrible, heartbreaking situation” in a press conference, adding that the footage was quickly released in the interest of “transparency.”

“We know, based on this footage, the officer took action to protect another young girl in our community,” he said.

A number of mainstream headlines, all of which remain live more than twelve hours after the body-camera footage was released, ignore what is arguably the most important detail about the incident: that Bryant was armed and in the process of assaulting someone when she was killed — and instead focus on Bryant’s race.

Axios: “Columbus police officer fatally shoots Black teenage girl”

Daily Beast: “Columbus Police Release Body Camera Footage of Fatal Shooting of Black Teen”

Slate: “A Black Teenage Girl Is Shot and Killed By Columbus Police”

NPR: “Columbus Police Shoot and Kill Black, Teenage Girl”

In fact, NPR even attached a disclaimer to its report stating that “This is a developing story. Some facts reported by the media may later turn out to be wrong.”

The Daily Beast article, written by a self-described “fiction writer,” begins, “A Columbus police officer shot and killed a Black teenage girl on Tuesday afternoon just as a guilty verdict was being handed down in the Derek Chauvin murder case.” How are the two incidents related? Well, the Beast asked “local Columbus activist K.C. Taynor of Exodus Nation,” who told the outlet “the latest police killing made it impossible to celebrate the Chauvin verdict.”

“It’s another murder,” he’s quoted as saying. “They’re animals. They treat us like animals.”

The Times’ writeup also appeared to intentionally distort a quote from prominent defense attorney Ben Crump, who tweeted that “a community in Columbus felt the sting of another police shooting as @ColumbusPolice killed an unarmed 15yo Black girl named Makiyah Bryant.”

While the Times quoted Crump, it quietly removed his line about Bryant being “unarmed.”

“As we breathed a collective sigh of relief today, a community in Columbus felt the sting of another police shooting” Mr. Crump said, according to the Times. “Another child lost! Another hashtag.”

The Times later added a line noting Crump’s “unarmed” claim, without including an editor’s note. In an email to National Review, a paper spokesperson defended the initial elision, saying the quote “is accurate and reflects his sentiment, without repeating what turned out to be inaccurate information about the facts of the shooting.”

The reaction to the story on Twitter from activists and prominent liberals also elided key facts. Some claimed, without evidence, that it was Bryant herself who had placed the 911 call, while others belittled the fact that she was attempting to attack a fellow girl with a knife.

Prominent Democrat politicians, including Senator Sherrod Brown (D., Ohio), also waded into the fray by trying to tie the shooting to George Floyd’s death.

Editor’s Note: This article has been updated.

You are out of free articles!

Don't miss out! Access premium content, videos, events, the National Review archives and more.

No thanks.
Login
You have 1 article remaining.
You have 2 articles remaining.
You have 3 articles remaining.
You have 4 articles remaining.
You have 5 articles remaining.
Exit mobile version