National Review / Digital
The Week

(Roman Genn)


Joe Paterno became a football coach at Penn State in 1950, head coach in 1966. His stats were astounding: 409 wins, 136 losses, 3 ties; two No. 1 rankings; five undefeated, untied seasons; 37 bowl games, 24 of them victorious. But he was equally celebrated for his sportsmanship, an ethos that could sound almost Greek: “Victory is contained within defeat, and defeat is contained within victory,” he wrote in 1989. “That’s the way it is in the best of games. What counts in sports is not the victory but the magnificence of the struggle.” A high percentage of Paterno’s athletes graduated; money did not slosh around the margins of his program, as it does in so many others. But even the best fall short. The exposure of a pedophile ex-coach, who used Penn State facilities as the scene of his rapes, resulted in Paterno’s being fired at the end of last season. Paterno’s wrong was to have reported an eyewitness account to his higher-ups, not to the cops. Could he not believe ill of a former associate? Did his own devotion to the team persuade him that the team would take care of the matter properly? Athletics is a behemoth attached, somewhat incongruously, to higher education. Snobs disdain it, often for bad reasons, but its supporters can equally be besotted. Dead at 85, R.I.P.


The Sound and Fury

After a tumultuous and bilious few weeks, the race for the Republican nomination is pretty much in the same place it was before South Carolina and Florida voted. In the first state, Mitt Romney saw a large initial lead in the polls turn into a landslide for Newt Gingrich. The same thing happened in reverse in the second. Romney is again the favorite to win the nomination

Some of the attacks on each side have lacked merit. Pro-Romney ads have distorted Gingrich’s position on abortion and insinuated, falsely, that ethical failings drove Gingrich out of office. A pro-Gingrich PAC notoriously produced a film full of untruths about Romney’s business record, and Gingrich closed the Florida campaign inventing a bizarre tale about Romney’s insensitivity to Holocaust survivors. In the main, though, the candidates’ arguments against each other have been perfectly reasonable ones, having to do with their records, temperaments, and electability.

All of the remaining candidates say they will keep going until the convention, and they may mean it. (Rick Perry dropped out and endorsed Gingrich before the South Carolina vote.) We are not among those who fear that the continuing battle is going to leave deep wounds that weaken the eventual nominee. The Republican party is not seriously split over any major ideological issue: Nobody on any of the debate stages has been making the case for Obamacare, or social liberalism. In this respect its divisions resemble those between the Obama and Clinton factions in 2008, which mainly concerned who would be the most successful champion of liberalism rather than what that liberalism should do.

Romney, once again the front-runner, devoted his remarks on the night of his victory in Florida to a sharp critique of President Obama. What he has not yet done is find a conservative cause to make his own and fight for, as Santorum has with the defense of blue-collar families. Romney’s short-term imperative was to tear down Gingrich, but his larger challenge is to slowly build conservative enthusiasm for himself.

February 20, 2012    |     Volume LXIV, No. 3

  • What the protesters don’t know.
  • A visit with the governor of New Mexico, Susana Martinez, after her first year in office.
  • Ron Paul’s ignorant cry.
  • The president’s acolytes decide he is a different sort of messiah.
Books, Arts & Manners
The Long View  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  
Athwart  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  
Poetry  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  
Happy Warrior  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .