NR Digital



The Iraqi Rotary
Yuval Levin hit the nail on the head with “The Hollow Republic” (August 13). I was reminded of a speech I heard in 2004 by an administrator in Paul Bremer’s Coalition Provisional Authority after the Iraq invasion. He said that one of the biggest problems to overcome was the absence of a tradition among the Iraqi people of doing things for themselves, at the local level.

The Iraqis had no Rotary clubs, no PTAs, no Little League baseball in which people selected leaders for themselves and solved problems peaceably through voting or consensus. All they knew was the family patriarch and the supreme leader, who for a generation had been Saddam Hussein. His dictatorship decided and directed everything. Under President Obama and the Democrats, this would be our fate: an all-powerful federal government controlling everything about the lives of its residents. (“Citizens” is too meaningful a term to apply to the subjects of such a government.)

This tendency of socialists was perfectly summarized in an essay called “The Law” by the Frenchman Frédéric Bastiat, written over 150 years ago. Socialists claim, he wrote, “that we reject fraternity, solidarity, organization, and association; and they brand us with the name of individualists. We can assure them that what we repudiate is not natural organization, but forced organization. It is not free association, but the forms of association that they would impose upon us. It is not spontaneous fraternity, but legal fraternity. It is not providential solidarity, but artificial solidarity, which is only an unjust displacement of responsibility. Socialism . . . confounds Government and society.”

Unjust displacement of responsibility — it’s hard to say it better.

Derek Lane
Via e-mail

Romney, Evolved
In “Like a Boss” (August 27), Kevin D. Williamson uses evolutionary biology to assert Romney’s superiority as a presidential candidate — especially where women are concerned. Noting that the man has great wealth and five sons, Williamson concludes that “from an evolutionary point of view, Mitt Romney should get 100 percent of the female vote.”

Actually, from an evolutionary point of view, at his age, Mitt Romney should be dead. From an evolutionary standpoint, America would be run by the biggest, strongest male. We could settle the presidential race in the UFC Octagon.

I know, I know: Williamson isn’t being literal. He does say that “given that we are no longer roaming the veldt for the most part, money is a reasonable stand-in for social status.” But that’s the problem with using evolutionary biology to score points in debate: There’s always a “reasonable” exception to its harsher laws for the people you want to win.

Jodi Compton
Morro Bay, Calif.

Kevin D. Williamson Replies: Ms. Compton argues that we “could settle the presidential race in the UFC Octagon.” Beats the hell out of Ohio.

Send a letter to the editor.

Get the NR Magazine App
iPad/iPhone   |   Android