Phi Beta Cons

Against Financial Aid


Roger Lott (John Lott’s son) has an interesting argument in The Dartmouth:


Thanks to Dartmouth’s outstanding financial aid program, my family and I pay only a small fraction of the College’s sticker price. While I’m grateful to have been handed the world’s finest undergraduate opportunities at so little personal cost, it’s unsettling to realize that in one year I’m sponging tens of thousands of dollars of other people’s money. As much as I like Dartmouth, I can’t say I value being here enough to justify the massive burden the College is bearing on my behalf. It may be time to make selfish free-riders like myself assume more financial responsibility for their educations.

Dramatic increases in grant-based financial aid have led to widening disparity in the prices students pay to attend Dartmouth. The growth in spending on need-based undergraduate scholarships from about $30 million in 2000-2001 to a projected $80 million in 2011-2012 has led to greater assistance for some, but has presumably contributed to the simultaneous rise in cost of attendance from $33,210 to $55,365. As noble as it is to want to help those with less, the College wouldn’t need to charge students from wealthier backgrounds so exorbitantly if others had to carry more of their own weight.

. . .

Need-based scholarships that discourage financially responsible behavior should be replaced with loans. Students of relatively limited means who will become doctors, lawyers or entrepreneurs ought to be able to repay loans to the College out of their future earnings.

This is similar to something I’ve argued in the past, and more generally, I think the idea of having parents pay for their kids’ education is silly. Not only does it create a third-party-payer problem (the person benefiting from the education isn’t the person paying for it), but it also introduces class disparities (a student with rich parents will have more opportunities than a similar student with poor parents). And then we try to fix the class disparities through government- and university-sponsored financial aid, thus creating another third-party-payer problem and rewarding parents who turn down income opportunities or fail to save (because if you make and save more, your kid loses financial aid).

Why not have all kids pay for their own education, either by taking out traditional loans or by paying a certain percentage of their income until their debt is gone? I can think of lots of advantages and no downsides: Schools and taxpayers wouldn’t have to act as charities; students would think carefully about whether to go to college and what to study, and they’d goof around less, because they’d be the ones paying for it; kids with bad parents would be less dependent on them; class disparities would evaporate, at least in this small sense.

Most Popular

White House

Bill Clinton Redux

Stormy Daniels could have stepped right out of the 1990s. She would have been a natural in a Bill Clinton scandal, and, in fact, all the same means would have been used against her. Donald Trump’s tactics in these cases are almost indistinguishable from the Clintons’. The effort to shut down the ... Read More

Encouraging Signs in Iraq

Last year, relations between the Iraqi central government and the Kurds reached what was possibly an all-time low when the Kurds held an independence referendum in which 93 percent of voters opted to secede. The timing was no coincidence: Iraqi forces had retreated from Kurdish territory in 2014 as the Islamic ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Do Not Congratulate

Do you want some good news out of the gargantuan budget bill now making its way through Congress? Buried among the mountains of pork and assorted unmentionables, there is one random provision I really like. It requires the Congressional Research Service -- which does a huge amount of very valuable policy research ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Top Trump Attorney Resigns

John Dowd, the lead attorney representing President Donald Trump in the special-counsel investigation, resigned Thursday, two sources briefed on the matter told the New York Times. [jwplayer PCWBu1GF-wKJ9CRQU] Dowd, who began leading Trump's legal team last summer, has repeatedly floated the idea of ... Read More

Thursday Links

It's William Shatner's birthday: Here he is in 1978 'singing' Rocket Man, plus a Star Trek/Monty Python mashup. Sold: Isaac Newton’s Notes on the Philosopher’s Stone. It was a long time before anyone admitted that he was interested in alchemy. High-tech forgery: Computer-generated 'Rembrandt' ... Read More
Film & TV

Superannuated ‘Idol’

In the pilot episode of Fox’s American Idol, Simon Cowell defined the show’s thesis: “We are going to tell people who cannot sing and have no talent that they have no talent. And that never makes you popular.” The show’s producers and its three judges -- Cowell, Paula Abdul, and Randy Jackson -- kept ... Read More