Phi Beta Cons

Too Much the Same

The new Forbes rankings have arrived, and there aren’t many surprises. That’s the case even though their author, Richard Vedder, is trying to rank schools with outcome measures (salaries of graduates, number of Rhodes scholars, listings in Who’s Who) rather than U.S. News’s input and reputation measures.

The top of Forbes’s list hasn’t deviated dramatically from U.S. News’s list since it started in 2008. This year’s top ten include Williams, Princeton, West Point, Amherst, Stanford, Harvard, Haverford, University of Chicago, MIT, and the Air Force Academy.

There are, of course, a few differences. Haverford is a surprise, and Yale is only at No. 14, and undoubtedly the differences multiply when one goes down the list. But the Forbes rankings show that, by and large, the top schools judged by inputs and reputation are still the top schools, even when ranked by salary and Who’s Who.

So maybe they are, in fact, the top schools! But there’s an important fact we should not forget: Colleges that attract the most accomplished and ambitious high schoolers are likely to produce the most accomplished and ambitious graduates. That will be the case even if those students listen to professorial dogma and get easy “A’s” for the four years before they get their diploma.

Because students themselves are major contributors to their success, colleges strive to build a reputation that keeps talented teens applying (in many cases, only to be rejected). If they can keep the very best high-school students coming, they will have the best graduates, and they will perpetuate their reputations as great schools.

That’s why admissions officers are so important. If they’ve done their job well, the actual “value added” by teaching during the four years doesn’t matter all that much. That’s my beef with the rankings.

Jane S. ShawJane S. Shaw retired as president of the John W. Pope Center for Higher Education Policy in 2015. Before joining the Pope Center in 2006, Shaw spent 22 years in ...

Most Popular

Elections

About the ‘Suitcase’ Video

The video is more powerful than anything the Trump team has come up with to this point because (1) it’s video, which is always more powerful; (2) the story seemingly told by the snippet so intuitively lines up with the fraud narrative — Republican observers are asked to leave late at night and then, boom, new ... Read More
Elections

About the ‘Suitcase’ Video

The video is more powerful than anything the Trump team has come up with to this point because (1) it’s video, which is always more powerful; (2) the story seemingly told by the snippet so intuitively lines up with the fraud narrative — Republican observers are asked to leave late at night and then, boom, new ... Read More
Media

‘The Children of Pornhub’

In a lengthy reported piece for the New York Times out today, columnist Nicholas Kristof tells the stories of children who were raped or sexually abused and who had videos of their mistreatment uploaded to the Internet pornography site Pornhub. From Kristof’s reporting: Its site is infested with rape videos. ... Read More
Media

‘The Children of Pornhub’

In a lengthy reported piece for the New York Times out today, columnist Nicholas Kristof tells the stories of children who were raped or sexually abused and who had videos of their mistreatment uploaded to the Internet pornography site Pornhub. From Kristof’s reporting: Its site is infested with rape videos. ... Read More
World

Trump Pulls American Troops Out of Somalia

President Trump on Friday ordered almost all American troops to be withdrawn from Somalia, following similar reductions in U.S. military presence in Afghanistan and Iraq. The Pentagon announced that the majority of the approximately 700 troops in Somalia will leave the area by January 15. Many are expected to ... Read More
World

Trump Pulls American Troops Out of Somalia

President Trump on Friday ordered almost all American troops to be withdrawn from Somalia, following similar reductions in U.S. military presence in Afghanistan and Iraq. The Pentagon announced that the majority of the approximately 700 troops in Somalia will leave the area by January 15. Many are expected to ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Can Joe Biden Pardon Himself?

John Yoo argues that once he’s president, he can. He mentions the contrary possibility that the pardon power mentioned in the Constitution was understood to refer to a power to pardon someone other than the pardoner. He does not, however, defeat this possibility. He stacks the deck by presenting the argument ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Can Joe Biden Pardon Himself?

John Yoo argues that once he’s president, he can. He mentions the contrary possibility that the pardon power mentioned in the Constitution was understood to refer to a power to pardon someone other than the pardoner. He does not, however, defeat this possibility. He stacks the deck by presenting the argument ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Biden’s Unhelpful Mask Stance

On the menu today: Joe Biden brings his own problems to the national stage, declaring that he wants Americans to wear masks until the end of his first 100 days in office -- well after the 100 million most vulnerable Americans will be vaccinated! -- and warns that the nation’s death toll from the pandemic will ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Biden’s Unhelpful Mask Stance

On the menu today: Joe Biden brings his own problems to the national stage, declaring that he wants Americans to wear masks until the end of his first 100 days in office -- well after the 100 million most vulnerable Americans will be vaccinated! -- and warns that the nation’s death toll from the pandemic will ... Read More