Phi Beta Cons

Vedder comments on the dispute between Becker and Posner

Rich Vedder spoke at the John Locke Foundation’s Monday Shaftesbury Society luncheon meeting and while he was here, I gave him a copy of the recent blog argument between Gary Becker and Richard Posner on the returns to college education. Naturally, he has weighed in on that dispute and you can read his post on it here.

At the end of his post, Vedder contends that college education is a costly screening mechanism and suggests that top employers ought to consider hiring young people who have been accepted into good colleges and universities. He suspects that they would do every bit as well as those who spent years (and loads of money) going through college. If so, that would call into question the idea that the college experience is the cause of the high earnings of those with degrees.
A few years ago I posed this thought experiment to an old friend of mine, a lawyer who graduated from Harvard and Harvard Law:
Suppose we have two groups of 10 high school graduates. All of them have been accepted by elite schools — let’s say Harvard. The first group enrolls in Harvard, graduates, then the students go on to elite law schools. After graduation, they’re hired by prestigious firms and begin their careers.
The second group of students, all of whom desire to go into the legal profession, are simply hired by a prestige law firm and begin learning the business of being an attorney as apprentices. Eventually, they all pass the bar and become lawyers in the firm.
The question I asked my friend was this: After each group had been practicing law for 10 years, would there be any detectable difference in their abilities? He promptly replied that there probably wouldn’t be any difference, but if anything, the second group might be marginally better because they’d have learned how to write well at an earlier age.
Formal education isn’t the only way for people to learn the things they need to know and isn’t necessarily the best way.

George Leef is the the director of editorial content at the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal.

Most Popular

Law & the Courts

The FBI’s Corrupt Cops

White-collar criminals should hope for one thing this Christmas: that they get to live under the Horowitz rules. Michael Horowitz has testified that he found no evidence of political bias on the part of the decision makers who, under the Obama administration, relied on hilariously implausible “evidence” ... Read More
Law & the Courts

The FBI’s Corrupt Cops

White-collar criminals should hope for one thing this Christmas: that they get to live under the Horowitz rules. Michael Horowitz has testified that he found no evidence of political bias on the part of the decision makers who, under the Obama administration, relied on hilariously implausible “evidence” ... Read More
Elections

Diversity Panic Hits the Democratic Field

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before. An Asian guy, two black guys, three white women (one of whom spent much of her life claiming to be Native American), a Pacific Islander woman, a gay guy, a Hispanic guy, two elderly Caucasian Jews (one a billionaire, the other a socialist), a self-styled Irishman, and a ... Read More
Elections

Diversity Panic Hits the Democratic Field

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before. An Asian guy, two black guys, three white women (one of whom spent much of her life claiming to be Native American), a Pacific Islander woman, a gay guy, a Hispanic guy, two elderly Caucasian Jews (one a billionaire, the other a socialist), a self-styled Irishman, and a ... Read More
White House

Is Trump the Only Adult in the Room?

Donald Trump certainly is mercurial at times. He can be uncouth. But then again, no president in modern memory has been on the receiving end of such overwhelmingly negative media coverage and a three-year effort to abort his presidency, beginning the day after his election. Do we remember the effort to ... Read More
White House

Is Trump the Only Adult in the Room?

Donald Trump certainly is mercurial at times. He can be uncouth. But then again, no president in modern memory has been on the receiving end of such overwhelmingly negative media coverage and a three-year effort to abort his presidency, beginning the day after his election. Do we remember the effort to ... Read More
Film & TV

A Film for All Christians

‘The growing good of the world is partly dependent on unhistoric acts,” wrote George Eliot in Middlemarch, “and that things are not so ill with you and me as they might have been, is half owing to the number who lived faithfully a hidden life, and rest in unvisited tombs.” The passage provides the title ... Read More
Film & TV

A Film for All Christians

‘The growing good of the world is partly dependent on unhistoric acts,” wrote George Eliot in Middlemarch, “and that things are not so ill with you and me as they might have been, is half owing to the number who lived faithfully a hidden life, and rest in unvisited tombs.” The passage provides the title ... Read More