The Agenda

Brief Note on Global Budgets and Defined Benefit vs. Defined Contribution

Clive Crook writes the following:

In a riskier world, and one where industrial-country demographic trends are unfavorable, public support for pensions and health care will need to be increased. In the U.S., the Republican Party has set its face against this. Its plans to contain the fiscal burden of Medicare, for instance, involve a gradual shifting of cost and risk to the system’s beneficiaries — adding to rather than offsetting the pressures that the economy will bring to bear in any event.

What he doesn’t recognize is that the Wyden-Ryan proposal, like Domenici-Rivlin proposal, is based on a very different premise, i.e., that today’s benefit will be preserved, yet that a global budget will be used as a backstop to protect taxpayers. The idea behind competitive bidding is that it will encourage providers, including public providers, to offer today’s benefit at lower cost. Crook’s critique applies to earlier versions of the Ryan Medicare reform than it does to its latest iteration, which makes the same assumptions regarding Medicare cost growth as the president’s budget. To the extent that there is a gradual shifting of cost and risk to the system’s beneficiaries, Republicans are moving in lockstep with the White House. 

Reihan Salam — Reihan Salam is executive editor of National Review and a National Review Institute policy fellow.

Most Popular


Betsy DeVos Strikes a Blow for the Constitution

The Department of Education has issued its long-awaited proposed regulations reforming sexual-assault adjudications on college campus. Not only will these rules restore basic due process and fairness to college tribunals, but they also — given how basic the changes are — highlight just how ridiculous ... Read More
Politics & Policy

ABC News Makes a Serious Mistake

Today, across Twitter, I began to see a number of people condemning the Trump administration (and Betsy DeVos, specifically) for imposing a new definition of sexual assault on campus so strict that it would force women to prove that they were so harassed that they'd been chased off campus and couldn't return. ... Read More