A few more readers continue to howl with outrage about McCain’s education ad – it’s unfair, it’s a smear, it’s swill, the subtext is offensive and makes people think Obama wanted to take away children’s innocence. (I wonder how many would argue that there’s no subtext to Obama’s “lipstick on a pig” comment, but there’s subtext to this ad.)
One reader accuses me “backing up a rather dishonorable ad—come on, is this really what we need to be talking about?”
Oh, for heaven’s sake, do we need to be talking about Cindy McCain’s battle with an addiction to prescription drugs, as on the front page of the Washington Post today? Bristol Palin’s pregnancy? Take it up with the McCain campaign if you wish, but my argument is with those who are screaming that the ad is inaccurate, when in fact it gets the facts right. Obama’s defenders are insisting that he didn’t really mean to vote for what the bill text actually said. (I guess the bill’s emanating penumbras laid out the limits for the kindergarten curriculum.)
One of the specific changes in the law was to change existing standards for sex education from starting in grade six to starting in kindergarten. Even those who put together lengthy analysis of the ad and the bill never address why one of the bill’s original sponsors changed her mind and introduced an amendment to change it back to the sixth grade after it was approved by the committee.
Did any of the ad’s critics go back and quote the legislation? Did anybody else go back and find the later amendment to change it back to the sixth grade? Few if any. Instead of hearing specifics, you hear a lot of adjectives – it’s unfair, it’s dirty, it’s offensive , etc. Much of the argument has been in the vein of, “don’t bother me with the facts, this ad feels like it’s wrong.” Even a commentator I respect has given the ad a thumbs down because it “feels [badword]y and gross” [emphasis in original].
You’ve probably heard that old lawyer’s saying, “When the law is on your side, argue the law. When the facts are on your side, argue the facts. And when neither the facts nor the law are on your side, pound the table a lot. Ask yourself which side is pounding the table the most in this argument.
The Campaign Spot
Ad Critics Continue To Ignore Sponsor’s Later Amendment to Switch Law Back to Grade 6
The Latest

Sen. Leahy, Set to Preside Over Impeachment Trial, Taken to Hospital
The 80-year-old senator’s hospitalization comes hours after he was sworn in to preside over the Senate impeachment trial of former President Donald Trump.

The Teachers’ Unions’ Ransom Demand
Students and families suffer while the teachers’ unions flex their muscles.

Biden Administration Looks to Buy 200 Million More COVID-19 Vaccine Doses
The administration hopes to have enough vaccine supply for almost the entire U.S. population by the end of summer.

Top WHO Official: It's 'Definitely Too Early' to Conclude Coronavirus Originated in China
Michael Ryan, the executive director of WHO’s health emergencies program, made his comments on Friday.

McConnell Signals Support for Effort to Deem Trump Impeachment Trial ‘Unconstitutional’
The point of order resolution was put forward by McConnell's colleague from Kentucky, Rand Paul.

Federal Judge Blocks Biden Order Halting Deportations
President Biden signed the order halting deportations for 100 days on January 20, several hours after his inauguration.