A Common Argument for Legalizing Abortion Is Wrong

Legalizing abortion does not keep women from dying from it.

Share this story

Pro-choice activists at a “Stop Abortion Bans Day of Action” rally hosted by the Tennessee chapter of Planned Parenthood in Memphis, Tenn., May 21, 2019.

Karen Pulfer Focht/Reuters

Perhaps the most powerful argument for legal abortion throughout history has been the threat of what happens when it is banned: Countless women will die from backstreet abortions, we are told, because that is what used to happen before it was legalized. Legalization, so the received wisdom goes, put an end to all that.

This argument still has considerable traction in the U.S., where abortion bans are once again a live option in some states. One need not look far to find scaremongering about all the American women — especially poorer women and women of color — who will die in the new Confederate States of Gilead.

CM

About the Author

Calum Miller

Calum Miller is a medical doctor and a research fellow at the University of Oxford, U.K., where his research focuses on abortion policy internationally. @DrCalumMiller calummiller.org

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement