Well, ladies and gentlemen, this is it: the final installment of these notes from the Annual Meeting of the World Economic Forum, here in Davos, Switzerland, high up in the Alps. The previous parts? I, II, III, IV, and V.
(Incidentally, a reader has written me to say, โJay, if it werenโt for the Super Bowl and you, we would have no more Roman numerals.โ Iโm glad to do my part.)
A group of us breakfasts with Abdullah, King of Jordan. We are not on the record, Iโm afraid โ but I can tell you this: The king is very, very articulate โ you might even say super-articulate. His English is not exactly British, not exactly American. Sort of half and half. He discourses on the Middle East with more insight, clarity, and sense than any commentator on television. And I have the following thought: If youโre going to have a king โ and, as democrats, we donโt necessarily want one โ he might as well be the sharpest guy in town.
One more observation: If I were a radical, I would really, really hate him.
โAbdullah has to leave early, because itโs snowing enthusiastically in Davos, and he has to fly elsewhere. In previous years, I have described Davos as a sno-globe โ I mean, as looking like a sno-globe, one of those pretty little shakeups you get at airports. This year, I think itโs truer than ever. The fat flakes hit your face, and you know youโre not in Caracas anymore. (Not that Iโm from Caracas.)
(Which reminds me to say: Hugo Chรกvez did not get invited, probably because of the Forumโs great concern for a surfeit of gases.)
โWe have a little music โ or at least a musician. He is Maxim Vengerov, the great, young Russian violinist. He is given the Crystal Award, which many a musician, and many an artist, has won over the years. Vengerov is not only a musician, he is a UNICEF ambassador, and he has played for children all over the world. He has traveled to many hairy places. For example, as WEF father Klaus Schwab says, he has played for child soldiers in Uganda.
He doesnโt play for the WEF audience, which surprises me a little. I thought heโd play something brief and unaccompanied โ a movement from a Bach suite, or something. But he does give a graceful, lovely, and thoroughly enjoyable speech. This is amazing, because speeches about music are usually rot: platitudinous, wrong, boring, nauseating, or some combination of those.
On receiving the Crystal Award, Vengerov jokes that he may not be able to get it through airport security. (At least I think he is joking.) He goes on to say that he was โblessedโ to be born in Russia, and live there for twelve years โ and then to study in London, Amsterdam, Israel, and the U.S. All of this has โhelped shape my character and personality,โ and โhelped me to become a musician.โ
โMusic is healing,โ he says, and for once the statement isnโt treacly. It is โa power we often underestimate.โ In ancient Greece, they prescribed music to the ailing, Vengerov says.
He speaks of his mother, who โproved to me that music can do wonders.โ She founded an orphanage, and has โrescued many children from the streets.โ From the earliest age, โI have seen what music can do.โ And โthat is why Iโm thankful for this award, which is a great responsibility, and I will do my best to make my motherโs investment in art pay off.โ
I think Iโve captured the gist of the thing. And Vengerov achieves something rare: a speech the right length and sounding just the right notes.
โYou will want to know about a friend of mine in Switzerland โ a wonderfully brave, independent, non-conforming man. He shows up in Davos wearing a cap that depicts Bush as Che Guevara. It says, โViva la Re-Election!โ
Viva, indeed!
โI have made this point before โ in previous years โ but may as well again: It sometimes seems that the World Economic Forum, in choosing its staffers, hires them from modeling agencies. Perhaps itโs just a coincidence . . .
โIt is John McCainโs turn, for coffee with journalists in the Hotel Rinaldi. And he has โbrought along a friend,โ as he says: Lindsey Graham, his senatorial sidekick from South Carolina. McCain is not at his most articulate โ far from it. Perhaps he is a little tired from his work and travels. Itโs funny: President Bush is always knocked for inarticulateness, but McCain never is. Sometimes Bush can, indeed, be inarticulate; sometimes he is a fabulous communicator. The idea that Bush is any less verbally capable than McCain . . .
Anyway . . .
McCain handles the questions decently. I make a language note or two: He is one of those who use โDemocratโ as an adjective โ โmy Democrat friends,โ โthe Democrat position.โ Senator Graham talks like a cast member of The Andy Griffith Show. This can be effective, or not. In any case, I have always been an advocate of talking like where youโre from. What the hey.
Conversation inevitably turns to Iran, and McCain says that Bush must go before โthe American Congress and the American peopleโ before he does anything. I think: So much for the element of surprise.
McCain also speaks of โthe rise of isolationism and protectionism in America,โ which is perfectly โunderstandable.โ But, understandable or not, it must be countered. McCain is nicely clear on this point.
Toward the end of the session, McCain tangles with a member of the press. I wonโt name her, but sheโs tall, Greek-born, flame-haired, and L.A.-residing. McCain has always been described as testy, but I would describe him as beyond testy in this exchange. He is weirdly inappropriate.
Arianna interrupts him a couple of times, in what strikes me as a normal give-and-take. We do this in this room all the time. But McCain pounces all over her, pointing out that everyone else has let him finish his sentences. Thatโs not bad, at all: but he does this in the tones of a parent scolding a child โ when the parent is in a particularly bad mood. This is hugely awkward, sort of freezing the room.
I think, โThis is odd, for a politician.โ Politicians are used to give-and-take, and they know how to roll with the punches. They also know how to turn feisty, or obnoxious, questioning to their advantage. Think how Reagan might have handled this: โGeez, Arianna, had too much coffee today?โ And McCain has been in politics for about a thousand years โ successfully, too.
To me, the flame-haired Greek American comes out much the better in the exchange. And, as between her and McCain, on the question of the war โ and this is what the jostling has been over โ I am 100 percent McCain.
One more thing: A different journalist suggests to McCain that China doesnโt want to be a superpower. McCain is nonplussed, unable to answer (as I might well be). He finally says, โAnd maybe pigs can flyโ โ which about sums it up.
โWinding down this Annual Meeting, Prime Minister Tony Blair gives a speech in the Congress Center. He notes that this is his last appearance in Davos as prime minister. He looks forward to coming back, and โtelling leaders where they went wrong, and how easy the job is.โ
His speech is wide-ranging, but mainly addresses global warming โ Davosโs topic, not to say obsession. Blair is, as always, smooth, thoughtful, and amusing. Talking about Arnold Schwarzenegger โ everyoneโs American hero, for his position on global warming โ he says, โHe is the only political leader who makes me feel body envy when Iโm standing next to him.โ Blair also says how โfantasticโ it is that โwe have John McCain here,โ for he is โdriving the agenda forward in the United States.โ Blair means global warming, of course. He calls this a โmoral cause.โ
Years ago, our senior editor โ NRโs senior editor โ David Pryce-Jones referred to Blairโs โevangelical eyeballs.โ I see what he means, on this afternoon.
In the Q&A, Blair is really good, as expected. He wonders โhow we can tackle climate changeโ without including nuclear power in the energy mix. He says, โWe have to get over this quite false view that nuclear power offers nothing by way of the future.โ He further says, โIโm a great respecter of NGOs,โ and โpressure groups have an extremely important part to playโ in public affairs. But, โin the end, leaders of a country have to take responsibility for doing the right thing despite the pressure put on themโ โ and that means, by golly, nuclear power.
A bracing statement.
At some point, a religious leader rises to put a question to Blair. I donโt see who he is, and donโt hear his name. But, at the end of his question/statement, he says, โHad you not been prime minister, you would certainly have been a cleric.โ Laughter and applause in the Congress Center. Blair then quips, โI donโt know whether that generous applause indicates that many of you wish that I had been.โ
Another Blair line: โMy ambition nowadays is to please some of the people some of the time.โ (Blair is frightfully unpopular in Britain, on all sides, for a variety of reasons.)
A bit later, Blair maintains that the division in our debates is not between Left and Right, but between โthose who believe in an open world and those who believe in a closed world.โ On one hand, there are โisolationists, nativists, and protectionists,โ and on the other โ well, others.
Before leaving, Blair gets a big question โ on identity. โWhat is your identity?โ Blair begins by noting that he was born in Scotland to an English father and an Irish mother. This has the effect of renewing my gratitude for the word โBritish,โ and the concept of Britishness. This concept has been much under attack for the last ten or so years. And what Tony Blair is, is British.
He concludes his answer by saying, โI come back to values โ the key thing that binds people together.โ Values transcend borders, skin color โ everything.
Davos accords the PM a standing ovation, and this despite the Iraq War, which they hate down to their fur-lined boots.
โA panel then convenes, and it is the closing panel. John McCain sits on it. He tells the assembled Davosites, โI bring you good news: I think that the Congress will act very quickly on this issue,โ and the Bush administration too. Whatโs he talking about? Why, what else is there to talk about? Global warming. โI freely admit to you,โ says McCain, that โitโs very late and may not be enough, but I think that for the first time there may be some action on this very important issue.โ
My sense is that McCainโs global-warmingism is almost enough to make Davos forgive him for the war. In this, he is similar to Blair.
โAt night, there is a concert, as there always is on the final day of Davos. The Basel Symphony Orchestra is conducted by Lionel Bringuier. Whoโs he? Well, heโs 20 years old โ which is an extraordinary thing for a professional conductor to be. And Bringuier is a very good one. For my review of this concert, check out the New York Sun, here.
โThe following morning, I take a last walk around Lake Davos. Itโs amazing how the mountains change here, how the scenery changes. Things never look the same, even when youโre looking at the same things: It depends on the light, the mists, the everything.
But enough of my junior-high poetizing. Iโll tell you what I hear in Davos, with regularity, especially from American (left-wing) participants: Donโt worry about Ahmadinejad. The Iranian president has no control over the countryโs nuclear program, heโs just a figurehead, the other mullahs are much more reasonable โ Ahmadinejad is just an excuse for Bush and the Israelis to be belligerent.
And if these pooh-poohers are wrong? Will we ever hear from them? โSorryโ? What will their line be, post-kaboom? That Bush and the Likud drove them to it?
On that awful note, I will bid you farewell. Thanks so much for joining me, on this Swiss journey, over these many days. Iโll talk to you soon, when I tell you a little about London. Again, thank you, and see you.






Comments