‘Imagine’ a Better Song for America

One is being written by Californians who mourn the loss of lives, community, and memories.

Share this story

Kelly Kirshner installs a red ribbon at the front door of the house where she grew up and where her mother used to live, after it was destroyed by the Palisades Fire in the Pacific Palisades neighborhood in Los Angeles, Calif., January 11, 2025.

Carlos Barria/Reuters

‘We poured everything” into that house. Fran from Altadena was standing outside the remains of her home, destroyed by the most recent California fires, speaking to a reporter. “I don’t even know what I’m doing,” she said, apologetic for going through a litany of the people she cared for — her family, her neighbors, their community. “We haven’t even slept. We’re staying in a hotel. We have nowhere to go. We don’t know what we’re doing.” And yet, on one of her worst days, she has her priorities straight better than some of us — most of us? — do on our best days.

Fran appeared on social media the same day the funeral service for former president Jimmy Carter was held in Washington, D.C. At the service, Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood, as you may have heard or seen yourself, sang John Lennon’s “Imagine.” Talk of no Heaven and no religion seemed jarring in what is meant to be a Christian church, Washington’s National Cathedral. That natural response aside, the most charitable view of the song is that it’s an anthem for unity and peace. And apparently it was a favorite song of Carter’s, who was well known to be a professing Christian. But what the song extols ail us as Americans broadly and deeply: radical individualism, humanism, and a secular leaning.

KL

About the Author

Kathryn Jean Lopez

Kathryn Jean Lopez is a senior fellow at the National Review Institute and the religion editor of National Review. Sign up for her weekly newsletter here. She is the author of A Year with the Mystics: Visionary Wisdom for Daily Living.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement