It’s Time to Remove This Trace of Anti-Catholic Bigotry from Our Laws

The Supreme Court may soon have a chance to strike down Michigan’s prohibition of public funding for nongovernment schools.

Share this story

Getty Images

Blaine Amendments are bigoted laws that bar public funding for religious institutions, schools especially, and they are still on the books in many states. They trace their roots to the anti-Catholicism that swept the nation in the late 1800s. Facing an influx of Irish Catholic immigrants, politicians tried to amend the U.S. Constitution to prohibit direct aid from the government to Catholic parochial schools that were created as an alternative to the then-explicitly Protestant public schools.

That Blaine Amendment failed at the federal level. So many states took their own go at a “mini Blaine,” or a state-level version, to achieve the same aim. Thirty-seven states succeeded. Fast-forward more than 100 years later: The U.S. Supreme Court has examined many of these state amendments, holding that they discriminate against not only Catholic schools but all faith-based schools.

AM

About the Author

Ashley McGuire

Ashley McGuire is the author of Sex Scandal: The Drive to Abolish Male and Female and a senior fellow with The Catholic Association.

Grazie Pozo Christie

About the Author

Grazie Pozo Christie

Dr. Grazie Pozo Christie is a physician and a member of the Florida Board of Education. She writes widely on science and cultural issues — her work has appeared in National Review, USA Today, the Washington Post, the New York Times, and Angelus News, where she is a columnist. She lives with her husband and five children in Miami, Florida.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement