New York, N.Y. โ โAsk not what you can do for yourself or your country but what your country must do for you.โ
Thatโs the creed of today, Clarence Thomas worries, in a country of people who were once well-positioned to receive John F. Kennedyโs โAsk not what your country can do for you but what you can do for your country.โ At the time, ours was still a culture with โears conditionedโ to hear such calls to sacrifice and โhearts that did not resist it.โ
It was a culture, Thomas said, that had an appreciation for โdelayed gratification . . . something larger . . . perhaps something transcendent.โ Children were raised with admonitions to โLearn to do without.โ โPrepare for a rainy day.โ And to know that โNo one owes you anything.โ
He aired his concerns for the future of the country he loves on Thursday night at a dinner on the upper East Side of Manhattan hosted by the Manhattan Institute. He spoke 17 years to the week after he was confirmed by the U.S. Senate to the United States Supreme Court.
As if to remind us of how hard and unfair the road to the Court can be โ a topic on which Thomas is an indisputable expert โ Thomas cited Robert H. Bork, who should be on the Court, extensively.
Justice Clarence Thomas โ who is his Grandfatherโs Son, as he told us in his remarkable memoir last year โ is a โson of the southโ who โwas raised by a man who clungโ to a love of freedom and independence.
***
One wonders what Barack Obama โ who has criticized those who โclingโ to religion and the Second Amendment and other liberties โ would think of Thomas and his grandfather.
One wonders, especially, what Obama would think of Justice Thomasโs emphasis Thursday night on the critical necessity of originalism โ the only standard that works for judges, Thomas says. โWe are neither omniscient nor omnipotent. We are just judges. Like the Wizard of Oz, we are mere mortals.โ Thomas said there are only two ways to approach being a judge. The first: โTo try to see as best we can the framersโ intentions.โ The second: โMake it up.โ Thomas concluded: โAt least originalism has the advantage of being legitimate and impartial.โ
Yet in his debate with Senator John McCain on Wednesday night, also in New York, Obama said that he would look for those judges who have โan outstanding judicial record, who have the intellect, and who hopefully have a sense of what real-world folks are going through.โ
Odds are, Obamaโs response โ just like his previous promise that he would nominate judges with empathy โ didnโt set off alarm bells. As Thomas put it Thursday night, it is โastounding just how many of our fellow citizens feel strongly about our Constitutional rights but have no idea what the Constitution says.โ Itโs a shameful reality given, Thomas said, that the Constitution โis at least as easy to understand as a cell phone contract and it is vastly more important.โ
And itโs an off-putting reality, given that the judiciary was intended to be the โleast dangerous branch,โ the one that simply interpreted the law, as โthe framers structured our government that it be governed by the consent of the people.โ
But the people donโt know that. The United States Constitution is โa tiny document that goes unread.โ Americansโ ignorance of the Constitution โhorrifiesโ Justice Thomas.
***
At the end of every Court session, Justice Thomas reported, he takes his beloved clerks to Gettysburg. Especially after tough sessions, he wants them to be even more idealistic about liberty, the Constitution, and our country. In New York City, less than three weeks before Election Day, he recited words from Lincolnโs stirring address there:
It is for us the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced. It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us โ that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion โ that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain โ that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom โ and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.
Thomas implored those gathered Thursday night โ and by extension anyone and everyone who reads these words and their crucial reminder relayed here โ to โrededicate yourselves to the promise of liberty.โ And in a land where others have died for the privileges we enjoy, ask ourselves โwhat any of us has done to deserve to live as a free people in a free country.โ Let us rededicate ourselves to ensure that โtheir bequest, this republic, will not perish from this earth. And definitely not on our watch.โ
โ Kathryn Jean Lopez is the editor of National Review Online.




Comments