San Francisco Should Try Punishing Criminals, Not Businesses

A new city ordinance mandating nightly business closures in the Tenderloin both fails to address the real problem and hampers economic opportunity.

Share this story

People walk around the Tenderloin district amid an outbreak of the coronavirus disease, in San Francisco, Calif., April 1, 2020.

Shannon Stapleton/Reuters

San Francisco’s Tenderloin District is one of the most difficult public-safety environments in the country. Long derided by conservative critics, the concentrated presence of drugs, crime, and homelessness has made the community both unsafe and unappealing.

This led several Tenderloin hotels and residents to file suit in federal court earlier this year, seeking not monetary damages, but attention from local leaders and law enforcement. Now, city officials have given the Tenderloin some policy attention, but rather than punishing criminal behavior, they’re restricting business activity.

JC

About the Author

Joshua Crawford

Joshua Crawford is the director of criminal-justice initiatives at the Georgia Center for Opportunity and a policy leader with Public Safety Solutions for America.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement