San Francisco’s Justice System Is Breaking Down

Despite more money and more staff, fewer cases are being resolved, leaving more people in legal limbo.

Share this story

Supreme Court of California Civic Center, in San Francisco, January 22, 2026.

Smith Collection/Gado/Getty Images

San Francisco’s criminal justice system may be reaching a breaking point. A San Francisco Superior Court judge recently found Public Defender Mano Raju in contempt and imposed fines after the office continued declining court-assigned cases in defiance of a prior order to stop doing so. District Attorney Brooke Jenkins says the refusals are disrupting court operations. The public defender says caseloads are too high to handle additional assignments ethically.

Both sides have valid points, but the reality is that only one set of rules can keep the courts running and ensure defendants are not left without representation — and victims without justice.

SS

About the Author

Steve Smith

Steve Smith is a former peace officer and college instructor and is a senior fellow with the Pacific Research Institute.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement