A student at Reed College in Portland claims he was banned from class discussions mainly because he questioned a rape โstatisticโ โ even though that โstatisticโ has been debunked โ just because other students said they were uncomfortable.
Nineteen-year-old Jeremiah True told BuzzFeed News that his Humanities 110 professor, Pancho Savery, had warned him that his views on campus sexual assault were bothering other students โ before ultimately sending True an e-mail telling him he was forbidden from participating in the โconferenceโ portion of the class at all.
โPlease know that this was a difficult decision for me to make and one that I have never made before; nevertheless, in light of the serious stress you have caused your classmates, I feel that I have no other choice,โ the e-mail stated, according to BuzzFeed.
True said that although he had been chastised for several statements, the transgressions that ultimately led to the ban were him rejecting the idea of โrape cultureโ and disputing the โ1-in-5-college-women-are-rapedโ statistic โ despite the fact that that statistic has been repeatedly debunked.
#related#Yes โ banned for pointing out that a deceiving statistic was misleading. Itโs based on a survey of senior undergraduates from just two schools, both large public universities โ hardly a sample that represents the entire country. And it didnโt even ask the participants about โrapeโ in particular. Rather, it asked them if they had ever experienced any โunwanted sexual contactโ โ including โforced kissingโ and someone โrubbing up against you in a sexual way, even if itโs over your clothes.โ
True said he was also scolded for expressing the opinion that logic is more important than emotion โ perhaps not surprising coming from a professor who apparently considers his adult studentsโ feelings more important than factual information, even when discussing something as serious as rape.
Savery told True in the e-mail that itโs too late for him to transfer to another conference section, but that he welcomed him to discuss the readings one-on-one in his office. He also said that True can still receive credit as long if he finishes the final paper and exam.
UPDATE: Reasonโs Robby Soave reported that Savery told him in an e-mail that True โwas not banned because of what he said but because of a series of disruptive behaviors.โ
Soave also reported that when he e-mailed True to ask him about this, True responded by saying: โBefore I interview with you, you must agree to make โn[****]rโ be the first word in your article.โโ
โ Katherine Timpf is a reporter for National Review Online.
Editorโs Note: This article has been amended since its initial posting.






Comments