Taipei is bustling at night, as you know. It is one of those โcities that never sleep.โ But it is equally bustling in the morning. People are going to work, of course โ Taipei is a hard-working place, and they start early. But they also fill the parks.
What are they doing? Lots of things. Tai chi, as you would expect. And yoga? Can I tell the difference? Thereโs dancing, of various types. People dance in groups. And alone. A man dances with a woman, sort of ballroom style.
People chant. And sing โ genuinely sing. In Daan Park, I encounter a group of about 50 who are singing together, in unison. Public singing is a rare thing in America, I find.
You got people playing badminton. I see a game of croquet. But, as in parks everywhere, lots of people just stroll or sit.
Very visible in this city โ particularly in its parks โ are old people. They seem more integrated than they do where I live. They often have nurses or assistants with them, but they also have people who look like their sons or daughters.
People in wheelchairs are on the fringes of the tai-chi groups (for example). If they canโt move their legs, they move their arms. They participate as much as they can. I have a feeling that some of these people have been doing these things routinely, for 60, 70 years. They want to keep going.
โFor previous parts of this journal, go to the following links: I, II, III, IV, V, VI, VII, and VIII.
โIn Part V, we met a Buckeye โ Shaw-Chang Maa, of the Straits Exchange Foundation. He earned his Ph.D. from Ohio State. Chung-Jen Chang is another Buckeye โ a Ph.D. from OSU. He works for the Ministry of Culture.
Chang is one of those who believe that โTaiwanโ is merely a geographical designation โ a name for an island. The name of the country is โRepublic of China.โ
He has worked in America, as well as studied there. โWhen people asked where you were from,โ I ask, โwhat did you say?โ โI said, โTaiwan, Republic of China.โโ Like many others, Chang found that Taiwan was often confused with Thailand.
โWe talk about the division in the Taiwanese media โ which mirrors, I believe, the division in Taiwanese politics. There are โBlues,โ who are more unification-minded, and โGreens,โ who are more independence-minded. โI donโt think thereโs much of a middle,โ says Chang.
โIn his view, are closer relations with China good? Oh, yes: โWe have more chance to trade, more chance to make money.โ If I have understood him correctly, Chang believes that ROC-PRC ties are key to the islandโs economic health.
โIโm curious about something: When did Taiwanโs media become truly free? When did government restrictions fall off altogether? Chang says, โAbout 1990.โ
โI pay a visit to a newspaper, the Apple Daily. In the lobby, I get a big surprise. Thereโs a bust of . . . Hayek? Yes. Underneath, there is an inscription, from the great economistโs Nobel lecture: โThe recognition of the insuperable limits to his knowledge ought indeed to teach the student of society a lesson of humility which should guard him against becoming an accomplice in menโs fatal striving to control society.โ
โThe editor of the paper is Wei-Min Ma. His parents came from the mainland, in 1949. I ask the standard question: Does he consider himself Chinese, Taiwanese, both? โWhen I was young,โ he says, โI considered myself both. But now I think of myself as Taiwanese.โ
I hear this a lot. And polls indicate that it is a national trend. There is a growing sense of โTaiwanese-ness.โ A developing Taiwanese consciousness.
But I warn you that this subject is tricky โ hard to be glib about. (What would writing be without glibness?)
โSo, I assume the Apple Daily is pro-Green and anti-Blue? That is, in favor of the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) and against the Kuomintang (KMT)? Ma says the paper picks on whoever is in power. And the party now in power is the KMT. When the DPP-ers were in, the paper picked on them.
Ma believes the paper must hold the government to account, plain and simple. Besides, he says, you know journalists: Theyโre like teenagers. They like to fight.
โDoes the government try to pressure Ma and the Apple Daily? Sure, the editor says โ but it doesnโt work.
โMa says that Chinese tourism to Taiwan will have a positive effect โ they will see a different way of life. A freer way of life. Relatedly, he says that people in China are envious of Taiwanโs free press.
Can they read it? Can they see it? In China, I mean. Ma points out that Taiwanese websites are blocked in the PRC โ but Chinese generally know how to get around the blocks. They โclimb the wall,โ as the saying goes.
โThis is nice: When planes from Taiwan land in China, flight attendants warn passengers to leave their copies of the Apple Daily behind. PRC authorities would not be pleased to see them.
I tell Ma he can be proud of this. Indeed he is.
โMa talks about journalists in China โ his colleagues, or would-be colleagues. Itโs very hard to be a proper journalist in China. Ma says that their situation is similar to the Taiwanese situation in about 1970: Some very brave people challenge government restrictions.
โThe Chinese government, says Ma, keeps telling people that China is too big to be free. That if the land is free, disasters will take place.
What a brazen line, no?
โLike most Taiwanese, Ma is unhappy that his country is kept out of international organizations. It stifles Taiwan. It retards its development. It prevents Taiwan from sharing its example, from showing what it has accomplished.
Participation in international organizations, says Ma, would give Taiwan advantages it does not now enjoy โ which is why China is determined to block Taiwan from these organizations. The PRC wants to isolate Taiwan completely.
I reflect that the word โisolateโ comes from โisland.โ
โFrom my discussions with other Taiwanese, I understand that the country would like to have at least observer status at the most modest, uncontroversial organizations: Weโre talkinโ the International Civil Aviation Organization and the Framework Convention on Climate Change. For gooโnessโ sake.
As you may know, Taiwan is allowed to compete in the Olympics under the awkward name โChinese Taipei.โ And Taiwanese beauties โ of whom there are many โ may compete in beauty pageants under the same name.
Well, you take what you can get, I guess.
โI ask Wei-Min Ma the terrible question: If the PRC moved on Taiwan, would the United States come to Taiwanโs defense? He says, quickly and somberly, โNo.โ At best, he says, the Americans would send weapons (which is a form of coming to Taiwanโs defense, true).
โThe trick now, says Ma, is to help China become democratic. Taiwan can set an example โ show the Chinese their future, so to speak.
If Taiwan and the PRC unified, at this juncture, Taiwan would probably lose its democracy. If Taiwan separated, if Taiwan declared its independence โ why, China would be very angry. Both the government and the people at large would be very angry. The Chinese would no longer envy Taiwan, they would simply be furious at it.
For decades, PRC propaganda has declared Taiwan an irrevocable part of China. (Same with Tibet, of course.)
So, says Ma, the best thing for Taiwan is the status quo โ the status quo for the foreseeable future. That is the position of most Taiwanese.
โMa says that people in Taiwan have the feeling that their country is just a pawn โ a pawn in a great game of East Asian chess, played by others. But Americans should remember something, he says: There is no country more pro-American than Taiwan. We have democratic values in common. Also, Taiwan is a model for China, and if China democratizes, that will be a significant benefit to the United States.
So, for reasons moral and geostrategic: โYou shouldnโt abandon us.โ
โOver the years, Ma has met many Chinese, including government officials, who believe that their system canโt last: that it will give way to democracy. Ma says that the process of democratization may be slow and difficult, but it will occur. China will end up democratic.
โYouโre an optimist,โ I say. Ma smiles and says, โTaiwan is too close to China for pessimism. We canโt afford to be pessimistic. If we werenโt optimistic, we couldnโt live.โ
My talk with Ma gives me a memory: When the Soviet Union collapsed, I said, โRemember, Jay: You didnโt think this was possible. So, in the future, when you think that such changes are impossible โ remember the Soviet Union.โ
Thanks for joining me, friends, and see you tomorrow.
To order Jay Nordlingerโs new book, Peace, They Say: A History of the Nobel Peace Prize, the Most Famous and Controversial Prize in the World, go here. To order his collection Here, There & Everywhere, go here.







Comments