The Problem with ‘Barstool Conservatives’

Dave Portnoy’s post-Dobbs pro-abortion rant should raise doubts about how well new parts of ‘the Right’ gel with conservatism.

Share this story

Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy at the World Famous 5th St. Gym in Miami, Fla., June 3, 2021.

Jasen Vinlove-USA TODAY Sports

Dave Portnoy can’t even deal right now. Shortly after the Dobbs news broke, the “barstool conservative” celebrity took to Twitter with an “Emergency Press Conference.” “I feel like I have to speak on this issue,” Portnoy announced. There followed 2.5 minutes of semi-coherent ranting, where he proposes that we are “literally going backwards in time,” that “maybe not everything is to a T in the Constitution,” considering it was written by “people who had slaves,” and that he’s pretty sure “95 percent of people in the country think like me — they’re socially liberal and financially conservative.”

That last statistic, of course, exists purely in Dave Portnoy’s head, as Ryan T. Anderson pointed out with a helpful scatterplot. Economic political preference is plotted along the x-axis, social along the y-axis, on a half-point scale where a -1 is “most liberal” and a +1 “most conservative.” Conspicuously empty: the bottom-right quadrant, precisely the quadrant that should be teeming in the world according to Dave Portnoy.

Bethel McGrew

About the Author

Bethel McGrew

Bethel McGrew is a widely published essayist and social critic.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement