What Is the American Heritage?

The static American bloodline that nationalists wish to defend against immigration has always been a fiction.

Share this story

The “American Flag of Faces” display at Ellis Island

Carol Highsmith/Library of Congress

A well-traveled friend made a wonderful observation a couple of years ago. In America, she noted, the question “What are you?” is a normal conversation starter. People know what you mean when you ask it: What is your lineage? “What are you” on your mother’s side versus your father’s? Americans know you aren’t inquiring about their nationality — that’s a given.

The Europeans my friend had met, however, found this question odd and ridiculous when she asked them. “We’re in Munich, aren’t we? What do you think I am?”

John R. Puri

About the Author

John R. Puri

John R. Puri is the Thomas L. Rhodes Fellow at National Review.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement