Where Do You Draw the Line?

While I concede the legality of the administration’s move against Rumeysa Öztürk, I reject its morality and prudence.

Share this story

Masked and plainclothes agents take Tufts University Turkish doctoral student Rumeysa Öztürk into custody near her home in Somerville, Mass., March 25, 2025, in a screen grab taken from a handout video.

TMX/Handout via Reuters

Last year, a Turkish graduate student at Tufts University named Rumeysa Öztürk co-wrote an op-ed for the school’s college newspaper complaining about the administration’s failure to respect student government demands for the university to divest from Israel. (Few seem to have read the piece; rather than a statement of antisemitic ideology, it is a bland “process” complaint about antisemitic ideology, larded with gratuitous quotes from James Baldwin — typically forgettable left-wing juvenilia, in other words.)

As a follow-up, on Tuesday of last week, plainclothes U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials detained and then arrested Öztürk on the streets of Boston without prior warning. She now sits in a detention cell in Louisiana, awaiting a deportation hearing. Despite persistent rumors that “more is coming” with regard to Öztürk’s activities in America, to this point, the federal government has offered no public evidence against her beyond the op-ed — and in this case none is required. For the secretary of state is indeed granted statutorily broad discretion to remove noncitizens from the country, as Andy McCarthy has explained in detail over the past weeks.

Jeffrey Blehar

About the Author

Jeffrey Blehar

Jeffrey Blehar is a National Review staff writer living in Chicago. He is also the co-host of National Review’s Political Beats podcast, which explores the great music of the modern era with guests from the political world happy to find something non-political to talk about.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement