Your Phone Data Belongs to You

A Supreme Court ruling protects us from government surveillance but should have gone even farther.

Share this story

A woman uses a phone as people gather at Times Square to watch the sunset during a phenomenon known as “Manhattanhenge” in New York City, July 12, 2025.

Eduardo Munoz/Reuters

Imagine if, as a condition of your citizenship, you were assigned a three-inch-tall police officer that you had to carry with you at all times. That tiny trooper would be able to monitor your exact location, listen in on your conversations, and see what you were searching for online. (Come to think of it, I may have just written myself a million-dollar check: This fall on CBS, Pocket Cop.)

Absurd? Yes. But no less absurd than the system currently in place, where virtually every American carries around a mobile phone that constantly collects data on his or her comings and goings. That data is typically stored on remote servers owned by large technology companies, so even if the mobile device were erased, a historical record of all the user’s activities lives on.

Christian Schneider

About the Author

Christian Schneider

Christian Schneider is a National Review contributor and writes the Anti-Knowledge newsletter. He is a co-host of the podcast Wasn't That Special: 50 Years of SNL.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement