In the 57-36 final tally, three Democrats—Byrd, Carper, and Ben Nelson—voted for Kavanaugh. (There were only 54 Republican votes for Kavanaugh, as Senator Dole was one of the seven senators who did not vote.)

Correction: Oops. A fourth Democrat, Landrieu, also voted for Kavanaugh (and a second Republican, Thune, did not vote).