Iโm delighted to pass along that Scalia Speaks: Reflections on Law, Faith, and Life Well Livedโthe book of Justice Scaliaโs speeches that Iโve co-edited and that will be released to the public next Tuesdayโhas received not one but two very favorable reviews in the forthcoming issue of the Weekly Standard.
Hoover Institution legal scholar Adam J. White praises the book as an โindispensableโ set of speeches in which โScalia educated, challenged, and entertained countless audiences.โ White calls particular attention to Justice Scaliaโs emphasis on (in Whiteโs words) โthe crucial role that educationโespecially civic and moral educationโmust play in sustaining republican government.โ (Relatedly: White is the author of an excellent essay, โAntonin Scalia, Legal Educatorโ in the new issue of National Affairs.)
I was worried by former speechwriter Barton Swaimโs opening observation that โIโm not sure Iโve ever enjoyed reading a collection of speeches.โ But it turns out that his use of the present perfect tense (โ[ha]ve โฆ enjoyedโ) is a ploy. Swaim finds, to his surprise, that Scalia Speaks โsomehow works.โ Indeed:
These addresses are beautifully constructed in their rhetorical expression and logical development, as satisfying to read as they must have been to hear. Thereโs a warm lucidity about Scaliaโs writing that nicely complements the oral form: Heโs always clear but treats his readers as people, not reasoning machines; his aim is to express his argument as cleanly and efficiently as he can, but heโs happy to stop and ensure youโre following the logic. And happy to crack a joke, too. Scaliaโs wit is legendary, but I was unprepared to laugh as much as I did. One example of many, on the absence of โsoccer momsโ in the Brooklyn of his youth: โThere were no soccer moms because there was no soccer,โ he writes. โAmericans overwhelmingly preferred baseball, a game in which a lot of players stand around while not much happens, to soccer, a game in which people run back and forth furiously while not much happens.โ There are people who write jokes for a living whoโd consider that their best work. [Emphasis added.]
Swaimโs discovery that he enjoyed Scalia Speaks far more than he expected to is, Iโm pleased to say, an observation Iโve received from several other early readers, including some jaded Supreme Court reporters who wouldnโt have counted themselves among Scaliaโs biggest fans.
So do yourself a favor, and buy Scalia Speaks now.






Comments