Bench Memos

Suncor v. Boulder Aims to Bankrupt the Energy Industry

Share this story

Suncor Energy refinery in Sarnia, Ontario, Canada, March 20, 2021

Carlos Osorio/Reuters

Today was the start of the Supreme Court new term, and with it came oral argument on Suncor v. Boulder County, a case on which much ink has been spilt on these pages. Having represented an amicus, the Coalition of Large Tribes, in support of Suncor, I attended the argument this morning. I have a few observations that I’ll put in individual posts.

First observation: Republican candidates, take note! The Democratic government of Boulder, Colo., is explicitly trying to raise gas prices, and at least Justice Sonia Sotomayor agrees with them. At one point during Boulder’s argument, Chief Justice John Roberts asked if Boulder was simply trying to evade what Justice Brett Kavanaugh described as a foursquare, on point line of cases placing emissions regulation in the purview of the federal government. Boulder responded that it was not and likened what it was doing to a “gas tax.” Yes, a gas tax. You know, the thing that raises the price of gas. This should come as no surprise; a former attorney for Boulder said the same thing last year.

Michael A. Fragoso

About the Author

Michael A. Fragoso

Michael A. Fragoso is a lawyer in Washington, D.C. and a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He previously served as chief counsel to Senator Mitch McConnell and chief counsel for judicial nominations and constitutional law on the Senate Judiciary Committee. He clerked for Judge Sykes from 2014 to 2015.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement