Bench Memos

Texas and the Senate as an Institution

Share this story

The judicial situation in Texas seems to be reaching an impasse. John Cornyn refused to return a blue slip on Elliot Gaiser keeping him from the last sure hearing of the year. Now it’s up to the White House and DOJ to scramble to get another pick ready for a theoretical December hearing and, more troublingly, on Chairman Grassley to break whatever china is left in the Judiciary Committee both to hold such a hearing and to see the nominee through.

The line in the Senate was that they break so much china in the Judiciary Committee that they periodically import more just to break it. Indeed, one longtime leadership staffer would observe that in the Judiciary Committee, after they break the china, they pick up the shards and go about breaking those, too. That’s why, I suspect, complaints about timing and paperwork fall on deaf ears to senators like Cornyn; he’s rampaged through many a china shop to confirm judges. Why stop now? The thing is that, when the Judiciary Committee has broken china over the last decade, it has been for substantive reasons — i.e. confirming nominees of national consequence — not a dispute over this or that pick to a commercial court in Dallas.

Michael A. Fragoso

About the Author

Michael A. Fragoso

Michael A. Fragoso is a lawyer in Washington, D.C. and a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He previously served as chief counsel to Senator Mitch McConnell and chief counsel for judicial nominations and constitutional law on the Senate Judiciary Committee. He clerked for Judge Sykes from 2014 to 2015.

Comments

On “Texas and the Senate as an Institution”

Advertisement

Advertisement