As we have seen before, Linda Greenhouse is fond of using the incendiary term crusade to stigmatize the cause of religious liberty, and she has even faulted other liberal commentators for giving effect to an โimpulse not to appear unduly antagonistic toward religion.โ So itโs not surprising to see her (or her editors) miscast a new case on the Courtโs docket, Groff v. DeJoy, as โThe Latest Crusade to Place Religion Over the Rest of Civil Society.โ
Greenhouseโs analysis is once again as shoddy as her anti-religious bigotry. The legal issue in Groff concerns the scope of protection that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 provides employees. Title VII forbids employers from discriminating against (or otherwise adversely affecting the status of) an employee because of the employeeโs religion. In 1972 Congress added this definition of โreligionโ to Title VII:
The term โreligionโ includes all aspects of religious observance and practice, as well as belief, unless an employer demonstrates that he is unable to reasonably accommodate to an employeeโs or prospective employeeโs religious observance or practice without undue hardship on the conduct of the employerโs business. [Emphasis added.]
The grand crusader in the case is a postal worker, Gerald E. Groff, whose religious beliefs call for him to observe Sunday as his sabbath. His terrifying crusade seeks to have the Postal Service accommodate his religious observance. (Amazon hired the Postal Service to do Sunday deliveries.) The legal question posed by Groffโs certiorari petition is whether the Court should revisit the statement in its 1977 decision in Trans World Airlines v. Hardison that an employer faces an โundue hardshipโ whenever accommodating an employeeโs religious observance would require it โto bear more than a de minimis cost.โ
Iโm not going to undertake here to present a full account of the competing arguments in Groff. (The merits briefs havenโt been filed yet.) Iโll instead just note some of Greenhouseโs errors and omissions:
1. Perhaps most striking, Greenhouse fails to mention that her usual judicial heroes, Thurgood Marshall and William Brennan, vigorously dissented in Hardison. In his dissent, Marshall (joined by Brennan) expressed bewilderment that โsimple English usage permits โundue burdenโ to be interpreted to mean โmore than de minimis cost,โโ and he condemned the decision as โdeal[ing] a fatal blow to all efforts under Title VII to accommodate work requirements to religious practices.โ
2. Greenhouse observes, as though it were a defense rather than an indictment, that the decision in Hardison โreflected the spirit of the timesโ by โ[t]reating religion as nothing particularly special.โ
3. Greenhouse charges that disapproving the โde minimisโ statement in Hardison would be โbold activismโ that would deviate from the strong stare decisis to which statutory interpretations are entitled. She does not inform her readers of (much less offer any response to) Groffโs argument that the statement was dictaโabout a then-existing EEOC guideline, not Title VIIโs definition of โreligionโโand is entitled to no precedential weight.
4. Greenhouse contends that Hardison โis clearly in tension with the current courtโs [supposed] privileging of religious claims above all others.โ But as Justice Gorsuch explained two years ago (in a dissent from denial of certiorari in another case), the courts โare far more demandingโ in applying the undue-hardship standard under other civil-rights statutes that Congress has enacted since Hardison, so โTitle VIIโs right to religious exercise has become the odd man out.โ Far from โprivileging โฆ religious claims above all othersโ (Greenhouseโs charge), overruling Hardison would enable the Court to ensure that religious claims under Title VII are treated the same as claims under those other statutes.
5. Even as she states that โ[i]t may just be a coincidence,โ Greenhouse insinuates that there might be something nefarious about the fact that the Court, after denying review in cases involving a Jehovahโs Witness and Seventh-day Adventists, granted certiorari in a case in which the plaintiff is an evangelical Christian. But the Court has all sorts of procedural reasons for denying review. More to the point, a victory for rural postal carrier Groff would, contra Greenhouse, be โa vindication of minority rightsโโa powerless individual standing up to the combined force of the Postal Service and Amazonโand it would redound to the benefit of all religious claimants.
6. Greenhouse asserts that a victory for Groff would โsignify the courtโs complete identification with the movement in the countryโs politics to elevate religion over all other elements of civil society.โ I have no idea what that means. Does she think that employment with the Postal Service is an important part of โcivil societyโ?
7. Greenhouse closes by declaring that โReligion is the lens through which the current [Supreme Court] majority views American society.โ I also have no idea what that means. But she citesโtada!โherself as authority: she links to what I will very charitably call an unpersuasive piece of hers on Dobbs as she harrumphs that โthere is no other way to understand the overturning of Roe v. Wade.โ






Comments