Bench Memos

The REALLY SAVE America Act

Share this story

The sun sets behind the U.S. Capitol dome in Washington, D.C., September 29, 2025.

Nathan Howard/Reuters

This week, the Supreme Court held that Congress has deferred to the states with regard to what counts as Election Day — thereby allowing them to count absentee ballots that are received late — and that the 14th Amendment’s citizenship clause does indeed confer birthright citizenship. Predictably, this has amplified the clamor to nuke the filibuster and pass the SAVE America Act.

The SAVE America Act, however, would not actually address these matters. Indeed, there’s a case to be made that Democrats should support it. Yes, its ban on mail-in voting would moot the late-ballot decision, but only after disrupting Republican get-out-the-vote operations in rural states while leaving such Democratic operations in place in their urban bases of support. Its citizenship voting requirements would likely suppress marginal Republican voters while having little effect on energized suburban Democrats. Its voter ID requirements would sow confusion and cut both ways, prohibiting such forms of ID as hunting licenses and concealed-carry permits. Of course, it would do nothing on birthright citizenship.

Michael A. Fragoso

About the Author

Michael A. Fragoso

Michael A. Fragoso is a lawyer in Washington, D.C. and a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He previously served as chief counsel to Senator Mitch McConnell and chief counsel for judicial nominations and constitutional law on the Senate Judiciary Committee. He clerked for Judge Sykes from 2014 to 2015.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement