A number of commentators on the shooting of a motorist by an ICE agent in Minneapolis have seized upon the Department of Justice’s Policy on the Use of Force, which was given a Biden-era revision in 2022 (all emphasis in the excerpts below is mine):
There are two problems with citing this policy as a basis for finding that the ICE agent broke federal rules on the use of force. One is the limited force of these kinds of policy manuals, which are internal department guidelines subordinate to federal statutory and constitutional law. The manual reminds us: “The Justice Manual provides internal DOJ guidance. It is not intended to, does not, and may not be relied upon to create any rights, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law by any party in any matter, civil or criminal.” Internal guidelines are, of course, often cited as evidence of the standard of care and used to determine whether excessive force was used in a given case. But, as Jim Geraghty and Andrew McCarthy have already explained, the general standard of reasonableness of the use of force is what would govern this particular instance, with specific guidelines of this nature being merely evidence of whether the officer’s conduct reflected a reasonable fear of death or bodily harm to himself or others.






Comments
On “About That DOJ Policy on the Use of Force”