This is pure theory, as I donโt know the man and donโt know anything about his private meetings on the Hill. But this whole business about how heโs no John Roberts and heโs going to have a much rougher time and all that may just be a fantastic job of White House and Republican spin. Alitoโs own performance when Bush announced his nomination was as dazzling as Robertsโs was. Heโs been a judge for 15 years, and so speaking in public is entirely familiar to him. And as is always the case, when the public is actually watching these hearings, the dramatic structure of them always tends to invoke sympathy for the person testifying โin part because the senators invariably come across like hectoring jerks. Donโt be surprised if, by the end of tomorrow, youโre hearing the same kind of talk about Alito that you heard about Roberts during Day 2 of his hearings. Oh, and all this nonsense about how heโs going to be beaten up about the wiretapping stuffโthatโs precisely the kind of question he cannot answer, so the Democratic senators are going to appear to be even more bullying and nasty if they keep yelling at him about it.
Share this story

About the Author
John Podhoretz is the editor of Commentary.
Advertisement
Advertisement





Comments