In the pages of National Review more than 60 years ago, Russell Kirk was thinking about the state of conservatism in Italy. Kirk believed that the “failure to present the traditional American arguments for ordered liberty is a contributory cause of the present intellectual ascendancy of Communists and Socialists in Italy.” As a result, the “Italian conservatives . . . have been left isolated and uninformed, and the extensive literature of American conservatism has been made known to Italians only through occasional wild diatribes against it in the radical newspapers and magazines.”
Kirk’s concern for the fate of Italian conservatives would seem to justify Michael Brendan Dougherty’s contention last week, inspired by the victory of Giorgia Meloni to become Italy’s prime minister, that American conservatives and European ones — including those outside the Anglo-American tradition — have more in common than some would like to admit. “Buckley, National Review, and the conservative movement they represented were extremely attentive to Europe, and generally cheerleaders, not critics or opponents, of various European right-wingers and nationalists who were resisting communism — from Cardinal Mindszenty in Hungary to Francisco Franco in Spain,” Michael writes, because “Buckley’s conservatism shared civilizational roots with these figures that extended beyond the Scottish Enlightenment.” He mentions Buckley’s running pieces by the Austro-Hungarian monarchist aristocrat Erik von Kuehnelt-Leddihn as further proof of American conservatism’s European ties.






Comments