Andy has written another great two-parter on the evidentiary bait-and-switch that Judge Merchan has used in the Trump hush-money trial to allow prosecutors to tell the jury about guilty pleas and settlements for federal campaign-finance-law violations. The prosecution wants these before the jury for the purpose of convincing the jury that the payments to Stormy Daniels were illegal under the federal campaign-finance laws, and thus that Donald Trump knew he was covering up those crimes when he engaged in falsifying business records.
In fact, these are egregious abuses of the rules of evidence, under which guilty pleas are not proof of a crime — much less of a crime committed by someone other than the defendant who pleaded guilty. Judge Merchan then pretended — Andy explains the pretense — that this stuff wasn’t actually being introduced for any purpose but to impeach the credibility of Michael Cohen and David Pecker . . . by the prosecution who called them as witnesses. We’ll see if the prosecutors actually restrain themselves from using this in their summations, which they’d have to if they thought Judge Merchan took his own cautionary jury instructions seriously.






Comments