Itโs no great surprise that John Thune won the secret ballot within the Republican Senate conference, picking up nearly half of the conference on the first ballot and outpolling John Cornyn on the second.
Thune has been essentially running for this job for two decades, and his role as Mitch McConnellโs right-hand man has only expanded with McConnellโs age and the health episodes that prompted him to step down. Senators donโt particularly enjoy outside pressure on their decisions (McConnell wouldnโt even say himself who he was supporting), and they didnโt warm to Rick Scottโs personality, either; he got just 13 votes out of 53 before being eliminated from the balloting.
But then, for a lot of outside MAGA commentators on Twitter and in talk radio, the campaign to promote Scott was mostly never about winning; it was about finding a new designated internal scapegoat who can be blamed for party and policy setbacks. Donald Trump and his movement canโt fail, they can only be failed โ and there always has to be an internal enemy so that the failure can be blamed not on attempting unpopular or unworkable things or on poor execution, but on sabotage.
Itโs healthy to be skeptical of the competence and good faith of political leaders, especially when they seem rarely to deliver what they promise, but itโs unhealthy for a movement to become so reliant on this particular form of argument that you can never afford to end the cycle of purges and mole-hunts, even in the immediate aftermath of a great triumph.
With the MAGA favorite J. D. Vance as vice president and Trumpโs trusted campaign manager as White House chief of staff, the scapegoat has to be found at the other end of Pennsylvania Avenue, and Mike Johnson now has Trumpโs support and is likely to be able to hold his caucus together more to vote for things Trump asks for. Thune, coming from McConnellโs leadership team, is now the obvious choice. Building a public drumbeat against his election is a natural first step to making Thune into public enemy number one.







Comments