Samantha Power, the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, wrote an interesting tweet: โFrom a wmn carrying a mattress on her campus to Afghanistanโs Wmnโs Nat Cycling Team, reaching true equality req showing change is possible.โ
I learned about this from Paul Mirengoff: โSamantha Power and the Analogy from Hell.โ (Power wrote a well-known book called โโA Problem from Hellโ: America and the Age of Genocide.โ) He learned about it from Katie Pavlich: โUN Ambassador Compares Struggles of Afghan Women to a College Student Who Lied About Rape.โ
As I understand it, thereโs a student at Columbia University who carried around a mattress to symbolize the rape that she said had been committed against her. Apparently, there was no such rape.
In any event, I am very, very familiar with what Ambassador Power has done. In fact, I had an essay in National Review a few issues ago: โThe Even-Steven Temptation: Adventures in moral equivalence.โ
May I quote several paragraphs โ short ones โ just so you get the gist? Here I go:
When I was growing up, the worst thing you could be was a racist. (And racism was often defined with grotesque, malicious looseness.) The second-worst thing you could be, probably, was a jingoist. An โethnocentrist.โ A flag-waver. Even simple patriotism was suspect, a sign of naivety and boobishness.
You were not to think yourself anything special as an American. You were not to be too big for your britches. Everything had to be equal, balanced, even-steven. The Soviet Union tossed poets into prisons? Yeah, well what about the Hollywood Ten?
At the time, there was a best-selling book called โIโm OK โ Youโre OK.โ It was by Thomas A. Harris, M.D. One of the original self-help books, it sold more than 15 million copies. Its title expresses the principle Iโm talking about: โIโm okay, youโre okay,โ or, maybe more accurately, โIโm not okay, youโre not okay.โ
If I raised concerns about what the Chinese Communists were doing to the Tibetans, it would fall to you to say, โWell, what did we do to the Indians?โ That wouldnโt help the Tibetans at all. But it would obey โeven-steven.โ If I said it wasnโt nice to shoot people as they scaled the Berlin Wall, you would say, โIt wasnโt nice to lynch blacks in the South, was it?โ
โGULAG,โ said one guy. โJapanese internment,โ said another (meaning the internment of Japanese Americans). โNazi war machine,โ said one guy. โDresden,โ said another (referring to the American and British bombing of that city). โImperial Japan.โ โHiroshima and Nagasaki!โ Etc.
Anyway, read the whole thing, if you like. The phenomenon I discuss may be very, very familiar to you.






Comments