The Corner

Democrats Can’t Stop Pretending They Didn’t Shut Down the Government

Share this story

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D., N.Y.) on the third day of a partial government shutdown, on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C., October 3, 2025.

Nathan Howard/Reuters

As a general rule, it’s usually a bad idea in politics to run away from what you are doing. Nobody who’s against it will be fooled, and you’re less likely to get credit with the people who agree with what you’re up to. Instead, the better practice is both to defend the battles you fight, and fight the battles you have to defend anyway. As I wrote back in 2009 in my postmortem on the Bush years, “the Bush Administration often ended up being pilloried for having conservative policies without getting the benefit of actually enacting those policies. If you are going to take the heat for something, do it.”

For a month before the current government shutdown, there was a vigorous public debate among Democrats and their pundit and activist class over whether they should provoke a shutdown. Everyone involved in that debate understood and acknowledged that this was a choice. Ezra Klein, in a highly influential piece in the New York Times on September 7, framed it as a choice and argued in favor of a shutdown: “In about three weeks, the government’s funding will run out. Democrats will face a choice: Join Republicans to fund a government that President Trump is turning into a tool of authoritarian takeover and vengeance or shut the government down. . . . Joining Republicans to fund this government is worse than failing at opposition. It’s complicity.” In Klein’s telling, Democrats should do this precisely because it would offer an opportunity to explain why they were doing it:

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

On “Democrats Can’t Stop Pretending They Didn’t Shut Down the Government”

Advertisement

Advertisement