Stephen Metcalf, Slateโ€™s โ€œcritic at largeโ€ starts a piece with this opener:

โ€œDavid Brooks is Americaโ€™s one genuinely likable conservative.โ€

Even accounting for poetic license, this is quite simply stupid. That this line made it by Slateโ€™s editors tells us quite a bit about the entire enterprise.