Allow me to add my two cents to the burgeoning literature on whether we should have serious concern that Donald Trump, if elected again in 2024, would become a dictator. Michael, Jim, and Charlie have already made many fine points about the often-impotent nature of Trump’s first-term efforts, the strength of the American system of checks and balances, and the strength as well of institutional opposition to Trump — which combined with those formal checks and balances to produce precisely that impotence.
First, the fact that we are even having this discussion is yet another reminder of the stark raving insanity of renominating Trump. I hate to have to keep repeating that in every single discussion of the American political situation, but everything else in our politics and policy is downstream of that decision. There is nothing — zip, zero, zilch, nada — stopping Republican primary voters from making a choice other than Trump. No votes have been cast yet, no delegates selected. Unlike on the Democratic side, where voters aren’t really being offered an alternative to Joe Biden, there are two plausible alternatives in Ron DeSantis and Nikki Haley. And if DeSantis or Haley is the nominee, there will be no serious discussion by serious people about their ending the American constitutional order. Oh, sure, Democrats and their flunkies in the press and pundit world will compare the nominee to Adolf Hitler no matter who it is — Harry Truman compared Tom Dewey to Hitler while there were still Nazis being tried at Nuremberg — but American voters mostly tend to write this sort of thing off as just rhetoric.






Comments