A good point about Giuliani from a true Red Stater:

โ€œ[Quoting me] โ€˜Alas, pick any conservative at random, and there is some issue on which, your conservative will tell you, Rudy is not โ€œsound.โ€ For me itโ€™s illegal immigration. For other conservatives, itโ€™s other things.โ€™

โ€œ[My reader then goes on] For me: Illegal immigration AND GUNS.

โ€œThe gun-NRA base is absolutely vital for getting out the vote in all red states and counties, and if it is Hillary vs Rudy every gun voter I know will not vote, probablyโ€“ sadlyโ€“including me.

โ€œToo bad because he is no wimp, but I dislike some damned urban โ€˜conservativeโ€™ like [name of prominent metrocon, not me] telling me I have to vote for him. No, I donโ€™t.

โ€œGuess 26 years here [in the wilder part of a southwestern state] has finally lost me my metrocon credentialsโ€ฆโ€

[Derb] Yes, itโ€™s sad. Such an attractive personality โ€” so MEAN (how I wish he were my sonโ€™s piano teacher!), but really, itโ€™s hard to see how Rudi (Rudy? please vote) has a chance.