The Corner

How โ€˜Expedience Ethicsโ€™ Busts Through Moral Limits

Share this story

greenleaf123/iStock/Getty Images

The New York Times has a long โ€” and, I must say, generally fair โ€” discussion of the contentious issue of embryo research. I wonโ€™t belabor most of the issues raised, but I want to highlight one aspect of the column that illustrates how some โ€œexpert ethicistsโ€ consider it a part of their job to conjure ways to bust through established moral limits.

When embryonic research first started, we were told that there would be a strict 14-day limit on researching embryos in petri dishes. At the time, I said it was all baloney, that the โ€œethicistsโ€ established the โ€œ14-day ruleโ€ only because embryos couldnโ€™t be kept viable in a dish after that time. In other words, they were prohibiting something that could not yet be done. But, I predicted, once the permitted research found ways to keep embryos going beyond 14 days, the rule would be repealed. And so it came to pass.

Wesley J. Smith

About the Author

Wesley J. Smith

Wesley J. Smith is an author and a senior fellow at the Discovery Instituteโ€™s Center on Human Exceptionalism.

Comments

On โ€œHow โ€˜Expedience Ethicsโ€™ Busts Through Moral Limitsโ€

Advertisement

Advertisement