The Corner

I Normally Dismiss the Chances of a Third-Party Candidate. In a Trump–Biden Rematch, I’m Not So Sure

Share this story

Larry Hogan speaks at a forum at Saint Anselm College in Manchester, N.H., October 6, 2022.

Brian Snyder/Reuters

During every presidential election cycle, there’s a stage at which we start to see columns about public disgust with both major parties in which authors claim there’s a real opening for a third-party candidate. Typically, I roll my eyes at the idea, and I have on several occasions written articles essentially pointing and laughing at the people writing them. But if we truly are headed for a rematch between Joe Biden and Donald Trump, the possibility of serious third-party challenge is something I would no longer dismiss out of hand.

To be clear, I’m still skeptical that anybody could pull off a serious third-party challenge. Whatever polls may say about the number of Americans who identify as independent, the reality is that most of those who will claim to be independent in a poll in actuality lean heavily toward one party or the other. The percentage of truly independent voters is in the single digits. Even if a third-party candidate can make some waves, when it comes time to vote, Americans do not want to feel like they are throwing their votes away or spoiling the election for the candidate they dislike less. There are also the advantages that come from being attached to a major party, such as access to ballots in all states, a built-in national organization, money, voter databases, a get-out-the-vote operation, and so on.

Philip Klein

About the Author

Philip Klein

Philip Klein is the editor of National Review Online.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement