I used to do a lot of work on immigration when I was at the American Enterprise Institute. But my files are long since scattered to the winds. Iโ€™m looking for the data which backs up the argument that during previous immigration waves, most notably at the turn of the century, many immigrants went home because they couldnโ€™t hack it here. Since we didnโ€™t have a social welfare state, only the immigrants who had the boot-strap gumption to tough it out stayed here. Iโ€™ve heard this argument many times and have made it, but for the life of me I canโ€™t find the numbers. Anyone out there want to help me out?