The Corner

Joe Biden’s Fate and the ‘Soviet America’ Debate

Share this story

President Joe Biden at the debate with former president Donald Trump in Atlanta, Ga., June 27, 2024.

Marco Bello/Reuters

Is America today equivalent to the Soviet Union in its dying days? That is the provocative proposition that the always-interesting Niall Ferguson advanced in a column for the Free Press last month. Ferguson has long believed the current conflict between the U.S. and China is a second Cold War. But now he is entertaining the possibility that the U.S. is not, er, the U.S., in this analogy, but rather the late-stage Soviet Union.

We should take Ferguson’s argument seriously. But the fact that, for his analogy to take hold, he must downplay the various problems China faces undercuts it. When others have made a similar case, I have rejected it. America, for all its current problems, still retains immense advantages, largely stemming from the parts of our vast, decentralized society not yet despoiled by political and cultural elites.

Jack Butler

About the Author

Jack Butler

Jack Butler is a former submissions editor at National Review.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement