…of ThinkProgress is, basically, unbelievably dishonest. He writes the following: “Podhoretz… suggested that [Jill] Carroll was suffering from a mental disorder.” I never suggested any such thing. I said, correctly, that people would might think she was suffering from Stockholm Syndrome — which is not a mental disorder in any case, but a form of post-traumatic stress. Unless Legum has dyslexia, he is perfectly aware that he overreacted to what I wrote initially and just isn’t man enough to own up to it. He also says I said he should apologize for what he wrote, which is also incredibly dishonest. I specifically made it clear I was parodying his own calls for apologies from writers he clearly despises. What could possibly be the use of such an apology?

About the Author
John Podhoretz is the editor of Commentary.
Advertisement
Advertisement





Comments