Ramesh – I probably agree with you that many liberals are advocating federalism in bad faith. That certainly seems to be the case of many pro-gay marriage neo-federalists who see nothing wrong with legalizing it at the federal level but who cry “what about federalism!?” when they hear of attempts to illegalize it at the federal level (assuming “illegalize” is a word).

Nevertheless, I personally see it as a step forward whenever the other side starts adopting your arguments rather than rejecting them. But I’ve got to go get ready for an engagement elsewhere. We shall continue this later, I’m sure.